3 ms·
With the way Bitcoin works, if you can point to a Bitcoin and say "that's my Bitcoin", you don't need the court's help to get it back. You could just issue you
by logfromblammo 11y ago
With the way Bitcoin works, if you can point to a Bitcoin and say "that's my Bitcoin", you don't need the court's help to get it back. You could just issue your own transaction.
Bitcoin are inherently bearer instruments. If you can spend the Bitcoin, you own it; if you can't, you don't. MtGOX owned all those Bitcoins, because it had to in order to do anything with them, and its customers owned promises made by MtGOX.
I think the court could have made that a bit more clear in its ruling, but I think there may have been an explicit effort to avoid comparing Bitcoin to banknotes. It doesn't matter if it's tangible or intangible. What matters is that there is no possible evidence of ownership that could be presented to the court to restore the property.
MtGOX customers spent their Bitcoins to MtGOX, and received promises in exchange. It was a nice attempt, but the straws eluded their grasp. They wait and get their pro rata share, just like all the other creditors.