3 ms·
> The moral question being raised here is about potentially hurting Apple users via irresponsible behaviour The logical next step is that Apple have been inter
by zamalek 11y ago
> The moral question being raised here is about potentially hurting Apple users via irresponsible behaviour
The logical next step is that Apple have been intermittently flippant about security (of late they have improved but their approach is still wholesale unacceptable). Why do users knowingly use an OS with this track record?
> anonymously informing the controlling party
With government surveillance could he have had any guarantee that his disclosure wouldn't have been snooped?
Either way this discussion can be argued ad infinitum. The real villain here is the European Commission for such a brain-dead policy.
- dspillett 11y ago> Why do users knowingly use an OS with this track record? Knowingly might be a stretch there. Many don't know any better either through lack of education on such matters or deliberate ignorance. > The real villain here is the European Commission for such a brain-dead policy. I'd argue that this means there are three villains, rather than the bad law being the one and only problem!
- zamalek 11y ago> I'd argue that this means there are three villains Good point. Specifically regarding Apple and EU: something really needs to change.
- coldtea 11y ago>The logical next step is that Apple have been intermittently flippant about security (of late they have improved but their approach is still wholesale unacceptable). Why do users knowingly use an OS with this track record? Perhaps because ever since 2001 there are 5-6 new stories like this with huge scaremongering headlines and "sky is falling" implications, and then NOTHING absolutely happens, at worse a tiny miniscule of OS X boxes are ever affected, and there are absolutely no implications for 99.9% of users. In the meantime, Apple, even if slow to respond to stuff like this, does improve OS X security infrastructure steadily. Meanwhile, in the same real world, people have to constantly fight viruses off of Windows boxes (slightly better after 8, but still a real concern). Btw, no it's not just about "small market share" either. Mac OS had even smaller market share in the late 90s (even 1/10 as small as OSX), but it still had lots of malware and viruses people caught.
- zamalek 11y ago> "sky is falling" implications, and then NOTHING absolutely happens Sure, just brush off a sudo vulnerability. > fight viruses off of Windows boxes Virus != vulnerability. Furthermore, while a rootkit is still a virus it's a long-shot from the relatively benign things running around on Windows machines (not that I mentioned Windows at first, but there ya' go - were on to that now). Just to avoid a Windows shitstorm, the same thing could be said of BSD. I am absolutely certain that there is at least one virus for the platform; however, the damage it could possibly do is seriously mitigated by the security of the platform. "Viruses" (used as a distinct term to "rootkits") can at worst log a few keys up until your next virus scan. After that, poof! They're gone. A "rootkit" (which requires a sudo/UAC vulnerability) can also at worst log a few keys or something. When you do your virus scan you're going to find nothing. It's going to sit on your machine until kingdom come because the virus is more privileged than you. Security is like a backup. You only care about it when you have the random bad experience of actually needing it. I'm sure there are a bunch of Windows users who lament turning off UAC now that their files are all encrypted by ransomware. It has nothing to do with "market share" and has everything to do with risk: "UAC is such a stupid feature." I could leave my keys in my car ignition every night of my life. No matter how much "market share" that car brand has all it takes is the random misfortune of someone on the street noticing that I do that. Just keep in mind that it was you that bought up all these tangential topics.
- fyolnish 11y agoViruses are not going to go poof unless your antivirus knows about them And in the typical case a vulnerability is a prerequisite for a virus. But local vulns are only a concern if someone already has access to your system. In which case your usually fucked anyway. Which is why Apple introduced developer certs and gatekeeper.
- zamalek 11y ago> Which is why Apple introduced developer certs and gatekeeper. Yeah that is a really neat feature from a security standpoint.