3 ms·
We saw this in Chess engines about 20 years back (when they started getting seriously strong) they play Chess incredibly well but looks very little like what a
by noir_lord 11y ago
We saw this in Chess engines about 20 years back (when they started getting seriously strong) they play Chess incredibly well but looks very little like what a human playing does.
It was fascinating to watch the changes in chess theory through that period as the machines validated or invalidated concepts and ideas that GM's had posited but been unable to prove one way or the other.
John Speelman wrote an intro to The Mammoth Book of Chess (that thing was awesome,I think I wore out three copies) which (paraphrasing horribly) that Chess is a realm of pure thought and that computers play it the way an alien might.
The best engines on commodity hardware now require offering pawn odds for a top human to even have a chance and their strength is accelerating[1] (stockfish now has a distributed test architecture to test for regressions which is incredibly cool[2])
[1] http://www.chess.com/article/view/how-rybka-and-i-tried-to-beat-the-strongest-chess-computer-in-the-world http://www.chess.com/article/view/how-rybka-and-i-tried-to-b... (Rybka was/is one of the strongest engines and in concert with a human it still couldn't beat Stockfish).
[2] https://stockfishchess.org/get-involved/ https://stockfishchess.org/get-involved/
- zzalpha 11y agoPlus, computer chess, with its alien moves, opened up human thinking on chess, which ties in with the article's point about neural nets causing humans to see our own world differently.
- noir_lord 11y agoIndeed (was just editing to clarify on that :) ). It led to something of a renaissance in chess theory. What I'd love to see (and have been tempted to take a crack at) is an engine built purely to play like a strong human with variable strength (things like not always taking the strongest move but not playing like god and then blundering either, not always avoiding mate in 27 plies and such). Shredder does it pretty well but it still feels like a machine, ChessMaster with The King got the closest I've seen.
- tcbawo 11y agoThat would be interesting. It would have to simulate human distraction and emotional ebbs and flows. I imagine ot taking into account feelings like impatience, boredom, and overeagerness.
- idlewords 11y agoThis is particularly evident in endgames. Forced mates have been discovered that require hundreds of apparently random and pointless moves, until suddenly the king is cornered and mated. There's a nice discussion of some of these on Krabbé's chess blog: http://timkr.home.xs4all.nl/chess/perfect.htm http://timkr.home.xs4all.nl/chess/perfect.htm
- minikomi 11y agoWow.. do the games change when it's computer vs human as opposed to computer vs computer?
- noir_lord 11y agoOnce you are inside the horizon of an endgame tablebase (currently 7 pieces on the board or fewer) then the end is known, at that point the computer plays the game like a hypothetical god would.
- iofj 11y agoKeep in mind that chess engines are heuristics based hill-climbers (essentially they enumerate all their options, then optimize that process). That these don't respond the way a human mind does is quite understandable. Deep-learning networks should already be a lot closer to how a human mind would react.
- adrianN 11y agoI disagree. Only because the architecture reminds one more of a brain this doesn't imply that it "thinks" even remotely similar to a brain, a human brain at that.
- merb 11y agoI disagree with you. The computer brain would still think the same as we do, but what do we do with our "thinking" process? we evaluate them based on emotions, while there is currently no way to have "real" emotions on a computer. Humans will always do their decisions based on emotions and not logically, we think way to fuzzy that any program could (yet) do it like that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]