5 ms·
When effective cultural participation requires keeping up to date with at least some of Hollywood's products, choosing not to view/listen is the same as choosin
by nitrogen 11y ago
When effective cultural participation requires keeping up to date with at least some of Hollywood's products, choosing not to view/listen is the same as choosing to be just that much more socially disconnected. See Moxie Marlinspike's presentation about this concept applied to technology:
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eG0KrT6pBPk http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eG0KrT6pBPk
When one oligopoly owns the vast majority of contemporary popular culture, we, the populace, should be expecting a lot more in return.
- tptacek 11y agoOne of my very most successful friends, by far one of the most socially and artistically connected people I know, didn't see Star Wars until his late 30s. He seemed to have suffered for that: not at all. Exactly, in as much detail as you can be patient enough to provide, how does "effective cultural participation" require you to see shitty new-release Hollywood movies? Is Marco Arment culturally disconnected? http://www.marco.org/2015/04/11/popular-movies-i-havent-seen http://www.marco.org/2015/04/11/popular-movies-i-havent-seen
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWhen I was growing up, we didn't have a television until partway through junior high. (One of the best moves my parents made.) I kept hearing these conversations in the hallway: "Did you see Starsky & Hutch last night?" (Yes, I really am that old...) I felt a bit left out based on that. But I felt left out because of a lot of things. I wasn't a member of the dominant religion. I came into that school knowing nobody, because I didn't attend one of the elementary schools that fed into it. I didn't live in the neighborhood (my parents got me to go to that school rather than the one I was geographically supposed to attend because it had fewer knife fights.) And, I was a nerd. So the actual amount I was "left out of things" because of not having a TV and therefore being unable to effectively culturally participate was... pretty small. That was in junior high. Today, it's even less relevant to me. There's a conversation about a movie I didn't see? "Nope, didn't see it." If they are uncaring enough to keep having the conversation about that for the next 20 minutes, well, I'll just do something else. Or I'll listen, learn a bit about a movie I didn't see, go to Wikipedia and read about the plot, and save about two hours and $7.
- tptacek 11y agoThanks for this comment (which is something I can say because I agree with you. :) I feel like, if you don't know where your local MLB team is in the standings today, you probably don't have a lot of standing to make arguments about US cultural disconnection.
- ghaff 11y agoAnd "popular culture" (whatever that means exactly) is so fragmented today anyway that not being up-to-date on even popular TV shows, movies, or books aren't exactly a recipe for social isolation. I actually feel like I'm at least reasonably plugged into what's going on in culture and I hardly ever see a movie in the theaters, watch a bare handful of TV shows, and don't listen to much current music.
- joesmo 11y agoAlmost 35, still haven't seen Star Wars in entirety, though I did own it on VHS for many years. Can attest that I did not "suffer" for it, though it has been a cause of awe and disbelief in others. Ok, just to be fair, some really stupid people got upset, but seriously, I wouldn't call that suffering. At this point, the movie's been ruined for decades--I just don't see the point of seeing a movie in which I already know what's going to happen. Also, IMO, from the parts that I've seen, it's just not that good. Of course, if you apply this to all movies, books, and music under copyright you'd not only be culturally disconnected, you'd be culturally dead, so I do think the original comment is spot on.
- nitrogen 11y agoOne cannot always choose one's friends and environments. There are indeed friend groups that would not be available to someone who has not watched Star Wars, or Jersey Shore, or what have you. There's no one item, no short list, of essential works that define the threshold between effective and ineffective cultural participation. But there is a compounding social effect for each movie/song/book/etc. someone doesn't know. Each additional water cooler conversation that one cannot join, and each additional movie reference missed, is one step further away from those friends. At some point, people stop trying to communicate with someone who doesn't understand them. Beyond mere socialization and entertainment, popular culture forms the behavioral and memetic vocabulary with which people communicate. As an example of how isolating cultural non-participation can be, consider how difficult it is for escapees from fundamentalist religious communes to integrate into society. That is the extreme end of a spectrum, and each decision not to participate in one's local popular culture moves one closer to that extreme. I'm not saying piracy is right; I'm saying that the choice not to consume is inextricably linked to a whole lot of other choices, including whether to participate in society at all. Given all that, it is unconscionable for Hollywood et al. to wield the amount of power they have demonstrated in the provisions in leaked TPP drafts and other laws and treaties.
- rayiner 11y agoPeople aren't pirating culture, they're pirating Mission Impossible. It's action-porn. It's a packaged entertainment-product. You're talking about peoples' right to food while defending their stealing Twinkies.
- tptacek 11y agoMy favorite telling detail in this debate is the extent to which people pirate fonts. Fonts. Vanity letter shapes.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoI haven't seen many statistics, but fonts are quite expensive to license. By the same token, few designers would be foolish enough to pirate a font and use it publicly; so I would think most font pirates simply want them for personal use, which can't be denying the foundries and typeface designers much income...
- twoodfin 11y agofew designers would be foolish enough to pirate a font and use it publicly Really? What about your local "mom & pop" design shops doing signage work for small businesses and ads for regional magazines? Are the type foundries that dedicated to tracking down pirates?
- nitrogen 11y agoVanity letter shapes. Without commenting on the piracy of fonts, and as a non-designer myself, this is definitely a non-designer's perspective :-).
- Silhouette 11y agoWhen effective cultural participation requires keeping up to date with at least some of Hollywood's products, choosing not to view/listen is the same as choosing to be just that much more socially disconnected. I think that's a stretch. Some things in life are essential to functioning effectively in modern society, like the abilities to have a stable home, to travel, to communicate, and to transact financially. Some infrastructure is then necessary to support these things, like sources of power and water for your home, effective transport and communication networks, and reliable currency. Losing access to these things is very bad, and so it is reasonable to consider measures like government regulation and universal/unbiased provision to protect that access. On the other hand, the world is full of people with different tastes and different cultures. Sharing some specific entertainment may provide a bit of enjoyable discussion around the family dinner table or office water cooler later, but it's hardly essential in the big picture.
- nitrogen 11y agoSharing some specific entertainment may provide a bit of enjoyable discussion around the family dinner table or office water cooler later, but it's hardly essential in the big picture. Then why bother with criminalizing circumvention and perpetually extending copyrights?
- Silhouette 11y agoWhere did I say I supported either criminalisation or perpetual extension of copyrights? Other than for the equivalent of other serious fraud in the former case, I support neither.
- TheGrimDerp1 11y agoagree. http://everythingisaremix.info/ http://everythingisaremix.info/