4 ms·
If a person is unable to lose weight on their own, even after a doctor advises them that it could literally cure a life-threatening disease, what does that tell
by logfromblammo 11y ago
If a person is unable to lose weight on their own, even after a doctor advises them that it could literally cure a life-threatening disease, what does that tell you?
This is the typical exchange in the US:
MD: Losing 20kg of body fat would reduce your other symptoms tremendously.
Pt: Great. Can you help me do that?
MD: No.
Pt: But I just gave you a $30 co-pay on a $300 office visit.
MD: I can prescribe pills to treat your symptoms for as long as you continue to take
them, and order additional tests. You won't know how much the tests will cost until
after you take them, and your insurance denies the claim to stick you with the entire
bill.
Pt: Could you prescribe exercise? Would that let me use my insurance to get a bench and
barbell or exercise bike or elliptical machine or something?
MD: No. Your insurance won't cover a preventative treatment that would very
inexpensively reduce your risk for literally dozens of horribly expensive diseases.
The assumption is that you won't exercise, even if you own all the necessary
equipment in your home.
Pt: What about a prescription diet? Could I go on Atkins or some other ketogenic diet?
MD: I can't recommend any diet in particular, because I don't want to get sued, or
censured and persecuted by the AMA. But yes, changes to your diet may or may not
help you achieve a goal of fat loss, depending on what the available research may
indicate.
Pt: What research? Can I read it?
MD: Are you a student or professor?
Pt: No.
MD: Then you probably don't want to pay Elsevier $100 a pop just to read articles with
ambiguous results.
Pt: What about liposuction?
MD: That's a cosmetic procedure. You can't afford it, and your insurance won't pay a
dime.
Pt: Fat loss drugs?
MD: None approved by the FDA that won't make your heart explode.
Pt: Why am I here?
MD: Because you want to help pay for my daughter's orthodontic treatment?
- rsync 11y ago"The assumption is that you won't exercise, even if you own all the necessary equipment in your home." You don't need any equipment. All you need to do is walk. Nothing else. Walk for two hours every day or two. It's also enjoyable and relaxing and mentally stimulating. It's win, win, win and it costs zero dollars.
- jacquesm 11y agoOr do your short distance traveling by bicycle if at all possible where you live.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThe dialogue was intended to be illustrative rather than informative. Health insurance companies, in general, absolutely will not reimburse for preventative measures, even if they are known to be effective. Every check has to have a diagnosis code attached to it. They will, however, give you some cash or premium discounts if you enroll in their health nagging/spying program. You self-report a sackfull of valuable risk factor information, and they, in turn, frequently call you and read from a script at you. There is no material support or genuine incentive for positive lifestyle change. As regular walking has such great, demonstrable health benefits, you would think that a health insurance company might do something like send you a free new pair of walking shoes if you send them your old pair, with the soles worn out from walking. I can't exactly agree with the part about being enjoyable, relaxing, and mentally stimulating, though. That's largely dependent on your route and companions. Someone walking through a sprawl of suburban McMansions with an unrelenting babbler is not going to keep at it as easily as someone who can enjoy a hiking trail at a scenic park with someone who knows how to just shut up and enjoy nature in companionable silence. (~Any resemblance to actual walking experiences is purely coincidental.~) The number one reason I have for keeping exercise equipment in my home is because I think you shouldn't have to get in a car and drive somewhere in order to have a positive exercising experience, and walking around my neighborhood is not one.
- jacquesm 11y agoLots of people are scared of silence.
- rsync 11y ago"Health insurance companies, in general, absolutely will not reimburse for preventative measures" Of course they don't. It's tautological. Insurance companies by definition do not insure against regular, predictable expenses. A car insurance company will never insure you for new tires and a health insurance company will never insure you for regular, recurring wellness checkups. Because math. Yes, sometimes they say they will, and sometimes such a reimbursement actually occurs, but make no mistake - that is never a claim payment and basically amounts to fee for service. You will not receive claim payment for items like this - they are not underwriteable.
- ZeroFries 11y agoThis problems the dialogue hi lights affect almost every part of the health care system, unfortunately. You have to educate yourself because otherwise you surrender yourself to only the information which is in the best interests of the current system to provide you. However, in this case, it's hugely beneficial that common sense wins the day, most of the time. Most obese people can lose a huge chunk of their fat by cutting out sugar, replacing it with fibre and healthy fats. Throw in a few walks a week and that's the first 100 pounds.
- DanBC 11y agoNotice I talk about lifestyle interventions, which is not the same as telling someone to just go and lose weight. A lifestyle intervention would include exercise (perhaps on prescription - cheaper gym membership) and a few months free access to a slimming club.