7 ms·
You missed one of the most important steps for most people with sleep apnoea: lose some weight. Most people with sleep apnoea are not helpless victims to an in
by DanBC 11y ago
You missed one of the most important steps for most people with sleep apnoea: lose some weight.
Most people with sleep apnoea are not helpless victims to an incurable disease. Losing weight doesn't appear to be easy, but it's certainly achievable for most overweight people.
EDIT: Here's the CDC page listing obesity as a cause for apnea http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/effects/index.html http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/effects/index.html
- arrrg 11y agoWhy did you deem it necessary to even mention that? I’m quite certain that people with sleep apnoea for whom weight is a relevant component are quite aware of that. Yours is just a pointless diversion in this context – because what exactly is the your angle here? Should it be hard for people with sleep apnoea to get treatment? I mean, what are you arguing here for exactly?
- DanBC 11y agoPeople are complaining about the length of time it takes to get treatment, and the cost of treatment, and that treatment is a racket. All that stuff is true. All that stuff is avoided by losing weight. Your comment appears to be overly sensitive to a calm, non-judgemental bit of information. EDIT: Here's the link to the CDC page which lists overweight as a cause of sleep apnea: http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/effects/index.html http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/effects/index.html It's really easy for people, especially men, to hit a BMI of 30 and not realise that they are obese. Especially in obesogenic societies where very many people are obese, morbidly obese or even super obese. This carries a range of health risks, most of which are helped by losing weight. It's weird the source article doesn't mention weight, since it is caused by lack of sleep (especially in children and young people) and causes lack of sleep (in adults). http://www.cdc.gov/sleep/about_sleep/chronic_disease.htm http://www.cdc.gov/sleep/about_sleep/chronic_disease.htm > Laboratory research has found that short sleep duration results in metabolic changes that may be linked to obesity. Epidemiologic studies conducted in the community have also revealed an association between short sleep duration and excess body weight. This association has been reported in all age groups—but has been particularly pronounced in children. It is believed that sleep in childhood and adolescence is particularly important for brain development and that insufficient sleep in youngsters may adversely affect the function of a region of the brain known as the hypothalamus, which regulates appetite and the expenditure of energy
- NotOscarWilde 11y ago> People are complaining about the length of time (...) All that stuff is avoided by losing weight. I strongly disagree on the point of time. It is important to realize how slow actual weight loss is. By my naive googling, losing 1kg of fat per week will require quite a lot of calorie restriction, and it is not achievable easily. If you are say 20kg overweight, you will need at least 20 weeks to lose that weight, likely more as nobody is perfect and stress factors here as well. I am stressing this point as I would like to encourage anyone who suffers from sleep apnea to start both treatment and losing weight. Telling yourself "I don't have to seek treatment, I'll just lose weight" may lead you into several weeks of diminished productivity (as a PhD student with apnea, when not getting enough sleep my scientific productivity is close to zero). I am not claiming any of the original commenters suggest this, but still: "I'll just suffer until I lose enough weight" is a terrible decision.
- DanBC 11y ago> It is important to realize how slow actual weight loss is That's a good point. > I am not claiming any of the original commenters suggest this, but still: "I'll just suffer until I lose enough weight" is a terrible decision. Well, yes, but treatment will change as weight changes. Why go through risky surgery if weight loss might help? Why go through the hassle of sleep studies and waiting for machine fitting if weightloss will help? The alternative to weightloss is not "instant cure", there's still time delays built in.
- wlesieutre 11y agoWorst case it doesn't help your sleep and only improves the other million things that being overweight is bad for. Darn. /working on it
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI lose about 3lbs of fat per week on the ketogenic diet. High fat, moderate protein, low carb (under 20g a day of carbs). I eat all of the cheese, meat, and vegetables that I want. You learn to love eggs if you don't already. Losing weight is not hard. Change your diet and start walking (just walking) 30-60 minutes a day. https://www.reddit.com/r/keto/wiki/faq https://www.reddit.com/r/keto/wiki/faq
- duggan 11y agoYou might be surprised how easy it is to become overweight without really realizing it. I slowly gained about 30kg (66lb) in my early twenties (I went from about 75kg to 105kg at peak over about four years). When I started having trouble breathing at night I knew there was a problem (and figured the weight might be the cause), but I didn't hear of sleep apnea until a few years after I had lost the weight (the breathing difficulty disappeared with it).
- arrrg 11y ago163kg, down to 84kg ±3 now (no longer overweight), knock on wood. I know all about this. That is why this condescending behavior is so awful.
- sokoloff 11y agoI think the condescending that you're reading is being inserted during the act of reading, not in the writing. (I could also stand to lose several stone.)
- toothbrush 11y agoI'm pretty thin by anyone's standards, and at the first few comments on weight/apnoea correlation, already my body- and/or fat-shaming warning lights were flashing. But yeah, maybe i'm just over-sensitive.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Thriptic 11y agoPossibly a bit. As someone who lost about about 100 lbs and kept the weight off, I've never really understood where this concept of "fat shaming" came from. I look at obesity the same way I look at smoking: - They are both self imposed, chronic problems - They both induce a myriad of known health issues - They both are readily solvable using known methods and by building healthy habits over time It is really imperative that obese people lose weight, in the same way that it's important that smokers stop smoking. You would never say someone is being "smoker shamed" by being told to stop smoking, that they are being "smoker shamed" by being told that their smoking is causing health problems, or that they are being "smoker shamed" by being told that smoking is not that attractive. Why should it be different for obesity? This difference makes me think that people view obesity as some inherent characteristic of themselves like race or sex. This simply does not have to be the case. I think if people knew how straight forward it was to lose weight by applying validated diet methods over time, there wouldn't be all this nonsense and controversy about "fat shaming".
- jacquesm 11y ago> I mean, what are you arguing here for exactly? I think that goes for you too. If you don't feel that the comment addressed you personally why over-react like this? It was simply a bit of information presented in good faith.
- arrrg 11y agoBecause this comment is a bad-faith derailment with no point to it. Something like that has to be pointed out. It’s also the typical shitty response overweight people tend to often get – people who are perfectly aware of their weight.
- DanBC 11y ago> It’s also the typical shitty response overweight people tend to often get That does not stop it being true! When a doctor tells someone to lose weight to help some health problem s/he's not dismissing the health problem. S/he's giving very good, useful, achievable, advice. In England the doctor may also give a prescription to 12 weeks free on a weight loss course, such as "Slimming World". You seem to think this is some kind of /r/fatpeoplehate or /r/fatlogic thing, but it isn't. Your dismissal of this calmly presented, good faith, evidence based bit of advice is odd.
- arrrg 11y agoAre you a doctor? Are you personally giving any individual advice here? That’s the issue. I have no issues with doctors giving someone advice – but that’s really not the point here.
- DanBC 11y agoSo you don't say anything about all the other medical advice here? This advice, with links to the CDC advice, is what gets your hackles up? In the UK positive pressure machines are only recommended after lifestyle interventions have been tried. http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta139/chapter/1-guidance http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta139/chapter/1-guidance > 1.1 Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) is recommended as a treatment option for adults with moderate or severe symptomatic obstructive sleep apnoea/hypopnoea syndrome (OSAHS). > 1.2 CPAP is only recommended as a treatment option for adults with mild OSAHS if: > they have symptoms that affect their quality of life and ability to go about their daily activities, and > lifestyle advice and any other relevant treatment options have been unsuccessful or are considered inappropriate. http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta139/chapter/2-Clinical-need-and-practice http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta139/chapter/2-Clinical-nee... > 2.4 Major risk factors for developing OSAHS are increasing age, obesity and being male. OSAHS is also associated with certain specific craniofacial characteristics (such as retrognathia), enlarged tonsils and enlarged tongue. Use of alcohol or sedatives can also increase the risk or severity of the condition. OSAHS has been reported to affect up to 4% of middle-aged men and 2% of middle-aged women in the UK. It is estimated that 1% of men in the UK may have severe OSAHS. > 2.5 Treatments aim to reduce daytime sleepiness by reducing the number of episodes of apnoea/hypopnoea experienced during sleep. The alternatives to CPAP are lifestyle management, dental devices and surgery. Lifestyle management involves helping people to lose weight, stop smoking and/or decrease alcohol consumption. Dental devices are designed to keep the upper airway open during sleep. The efficacy of dental devices has been established in clinical trials, but these devices are traditionally viewed as a treatment option only for mild and moderate OSAHS. Surgery involves resection of the uvula and redundant retrolingual soft tissue. However, there is a lack of evidence of clinical effectiveness, and surgery is not routinely used in clinical practice. Talking about weight loss in a thread about lack of sleep is not a derailment; it is not condescending. Lack of sleep is one cause of obesity. Obesity plays a major role in lack of sleep.
- beachstartup 11y ago> I mean, what are you arguing here for exactly? i'm pretty sure he's arguing for people to treat their own apnea by losing weight instead of dealing with clinics and the treatment "racket"
- rrss1122 11y agoIt is necessary to mention it. My impression is, the best way to go is to get the apnea treated first, most likely with CPAP. Once your sleep is improved and you get more energy, then you should get on a weight loss program, using diet and exercise. After losing weight, it's possible you won't even need CPAP anymore, and you'll be "cured" from apnea. This is why losing weight is one of the most important steps. The CPAP should make it easier to do so.
- bpatrianakos 11y agoThe process is the same for those with sleep apnea who aren't overweight. Like me. I weigh 155 and an 6' tall. Born with a small airway and just got lucky it seems. So if your point is that if people just lost some weight they wouldn't have anything to complain about then I'm not sure weight is even relevant here. It's a very lengthy and time consuming process regardless of the cause.
- mulletbum 11y agoNot defending DanBC, but if he was talking about "The Public" I think that would disclude someone with a small airway because it falls outside the norm. However, if he plans on making the suggestion that "the public" is all fat so they can't sleep, he should back it up with facts.
- crpatino 11y agoWhat facts? This is not a peer reviewed journal, you know. Here are two distinct facts: 1. I do have eyes and I can see a trend. * I do not recall seeing less fat people as a child, but I do recall seeing more thin people now. * I also notice that the fat people I see now seems on average younger than the fat people I recall from my childhood. * I also notice that the fattest ones - those grossly obese instead of merely overweight - are both larger and more common now than what I recall from childhood (and I was practically raised by an aunt that used to be at the very top of the scale back then, but somehow found herself surpassed in the last 20 years or so). 2. We are told by the media that there are statistics that show an epidemic of overweight. The study pointed out claims that physicians consider overweight as one cause (not the cause) of sleep apnea. We are now told that there is also an epidemic of sleep apnea. * If A causes B, and we observe an increase of both A and B. It is only logic that the "increase of A" is at least partially responsible for the "increase of B". * It would make an interesting scientific study to figure out the degrees of correlation between "increase of A" and "increase of B". It would be even better if such study could conclude if such correlation is strong enough to justify calling "increase of A" a driving factor in the "increase of B" or not. * On the other hand, it is a logical fallacy to claim that no conclusion can be reached regarding the causation/correlation between increases of A and B without "backing it up with facts". I will even claim that it is AntiScientific. If you start with that kind of attitude, you will never be able to form falsifiable hypothesis and therefore will be going through the motions of the scientific method without getting down to the substance.
- logfromblammo 11y agoSleep deprivation can cause weight gain. If you already have obstructive sleep apnea, it may be impossible for you to non-surgically achieve sufficient weight loss to improve your sleep. Basically, in order to (possibly) cure your apnea via weight loss, you have to treat it first, so you can get some uninterrupted sleep. And then, you still might have a constricted or obstructed airway, even with 5% body fat. An ENT specialist might be able to drill it out or laser it off, but that's still technically a surgery, with all the attendant risks, and obesity and apnea are both added risk factors for surgery and general anaesthesia. Better to have just one than both. So you will still have to go through the rigmarole which seems designed to maximize the number of insurance co-pays the patient has to make. It is possible to send the patients home with a black box, have them attach the two sensors themselves before sleeping as is usual for them, in their own beds. Then you can diagnose apnea from the black box data, and send a tech out to their home to adjust the fit of a new CPAP or BiPAP, to be titrated by an automated black box program. Afterward, the black box can be returned in person or mailed back. But there's the critical problem with US health care. There are strong anti-incentives to reducing costs in that manner. Reducing the costs causes the providers to lose money. Failing to do all the expensive CYA tests exposes the provider to malpractice complaints. The standard operating procedure is not structured around what is best for the patients. There is definitely an element of racket in it, especially if you are forced by your insurer to rent the CPAP machine.
- DanBC 11y ago> Sleep deprivation can cause weight gain. If you already have obstructive sleep apnea, it may be impossible for you to non-surgically achieve sufficient weight loss to improve your sleep. Sure, once you've tried lifestyle interventions and they don't work CPAP and surgery are options. Why reach for those risky options when a lifestyle intervention - and that's not telling fatties to go lose some weight - is much safer and carries so many other health benefits?
- logfromblammo 11y agoIn the US, the lifestyle intervention is telling the fatty to lose weight. Over the phone. From a script. I can easily imagine how, in nations with less sadistic health care systems, an actual human might show up in person, to do things like take the fatty on an instructional trip to their local grocery store, followed by example preparations of salubrious meals. Or the person might demonstrate beginner exercises that require minimal equipment. There might be an organized support group of individuals with similar goals available at no additional cost. The actual situation in the US is that if you have a problem that some weight loss might help to fix, you get a pamphlet or printout entitled (paraphrased) "Hey Fatty, Being Fat Is Bad For You!" There will probably be a deprecated recommendation to start a low-fat, reduced-sodium diet. There might even be a true factoid on it that you didn't already know. But no actual, material support is provided, whatsoever. If you need to lose 100 lbs., you are completely on your own, to not only figure out how, but to stick to your plan for the next two years. ...Unless you have enough money. In that case, you can rent a personal trainer and nutrition consultant, at your own expense. Weight loss (and other types of lifestyle change) is a for-profit business in the US. And the business is horribly inefficient. Americans spend millions on it, and are only getting fatter. A very large part of the business is fueled by ignorance and disinformation. So perhaps you can explain to me why lifestyle interventions are not seriously attempted in the US as part of medical treatment. What you say is true. It is safer. It provides other benefits to the patient. But few people can accomplish it without some form of external assistance or support. And in the US, that often comes at a price. By the time someone in the US actually goes to endure the gauntlet of getting some responsive treatment for OSA, they may have already been trying for several years to lose weight, without success. They may be falling asleep at work (in meetings, even!) or while driving. They need relief now, not in six months. That's why sleep docs in the US go straight for CPAP. It's a quicker response to treatment and a surer path to profitability.
- Domenic_S 11y agoFor sure, my sleep doc and I definitely discussed that and it's part of the plan. However, my dad also has obstructive apnea, and he is very much normal weight. He even had apnea surgery, and it didn't help at all. At my physical exam, the sleep doc said I had a large tongue which contributed (haha).
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoAssuming your dad is an American, I have to ask, is he a "normal weight" or his he "healthy weight?" 74% of adult males in the US are overweight or obese[1], which would make it the norm. [1] http://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statistics/Pages/overweight-obesity-statistics.aspx#b http://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statistic...
- Domenic_S 11y agoYour own NIH link has the following classifications: Normal weight, Overweight, Obesity, Extreme obesity.
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoThe vast majority of the time that I hear someone talk about "normal weight" they are referring to the average US weight, not the NIH definition. For example, I'm regularly called a "skeleton" or "beanpole." At 6' and 155lbs I fall in to the "NIH normal," but far below the "US normal." Were you referring to the NIH normal, or the US normal?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> You missed one of the most important steps for most people with sleep apnoea: lose some weight. While obesity is a risk factor for OSA, untreated OSA makes it harder to lose weight (or do lots of other things; it has a variety of physical and cognitive impacts.) If you have OSA and you want to lose weight to deal with OSA, that's great, but its not really an alternative to getting immediate treatment for OSA, rather, its an addition reason to get the OSA treated. You might not need continued treatment for the OSA once the obesity is resolved, sure, but that's a longer-term concern.
- Gdiddy 11y agoIt's certainly a factor for many people. But frankly the way you've phrased it is pretty offensive to me - a non-obese person with severe central and obstructive SA. You're also forgetting the confound that being chronically fatigued and having a screwed up cortisol, blood oxygenation and glycemic index (all due to lack of sleep), makes losing weight extremely difficult.