3 ms·
The mobile web sucks
- gaze 11y agoMaybe it has something to do with all the garbage that the verge loads every time you load the page?
- jschwartzi 11y agoLike the 4 identical ads from Qualcomm bogging down my 6-core desktop machine?
- 13 11y agoThat's rich, coming from The Verge. 245 objects requested, 48 JavaScript files loaded, 9.8MB.
- skore 11y agoMy first impulse as well. As the article states, though, they're aware of and working on it[0]. [0] http://product.voxmedia.com/2015/5/6/8561867/declaring-performance-bankruptcy http://product.voxmedia.com/2015/5/6/8561867/declaring-perfo...
- 13 11y agoWhy is their target 8 seconds to load the page? That's a ridiculously long time.
- gitah 11y agoIf iOS marketshare keeps going up, Apple will get sued for anti-trust. Imaging if Microsoft won't let other developers write web browsers for windows.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- andreapaiola 11y agoNope: theverge sucks.
- jay_kyburz 11y agoYeah, I don't know why everybody is pointing at browsers and saying the mobile web sux. I'm constantly amazed at what my phones browser can do. Its the content that sux.
- bobbles 11y agoI remember distinctly that the Verge was the first website I hated using on my phone. (As in, yes there are awful websites, but whatever, move on. As I was actually trying to read the Verge article.. i grew to hate it much more) They have that awful floating box that is a constant overlay menu on their articles.. not to mention its completely black! in stark contrast to the rest of the page.
- totemizer 11y agoLet me FTFY: The web sucks.
- Aoyagi 11y ago>"Modern" web sucks FTFFY
- CmonDev 11y agoYes, documents should not pretend they are apps.
- Aoyagi 11y agoSee, this is why I hate that word; it's used for absolutely everything, so I actually don't consider it to be incorrect when someone says "BBC's web app" and is referring to their website. I mean, I cringe a lot, but that's because of the word itself, not because of the meaning, which today seems to be "any kind of software".
- kennywinker 11y agoIs it too conspiracy theory-ist to notice that these articles trashing mobile browsing and Safari in particular come from an ad-supported site on the eve of Apple adding adblock to Mobile Safari? This isn't my observation, though I can't recall where I read it.
- CmonDev 11y agoNo, Apple is funding them behind the scenes anyways (based on their reviews).
- bgirard 11y ago| The page isn't redirecting properly ... yup
- welly 11y agoThere is a lot of terrible mobile websites out there, but some how I manage to get by. I simply refuse to have a mobile/native app for every website that is out there that I use. My mobile screen would be full to the brim with icons. As it stands, I'm able to have a single "Contrib" folder, which contains mobile apps I can't do without (Skype, Feedly, BeerSmith 2, Untapped) on my iPhone with the apps I use mostly on the first screen. I now no longer have to scroll through multiple pages and multiple folders to find what app I want. Why do I need a Medium.com mobile app when the mobile website works fine? It could be better, of course, but it works. Same with Facebook. I don't see the necessity to have a dedicated Facebook app on my phone when the mobile site gives me all I particularly want from Facebook. All the sites I visit regularly work fine on mobile - I do wish they'd dedicate more time/resources/money on their mobile sites rather than their apps but I suppose the marketing department calls the shots. Got to take up room on my mobile phone screen!
- byron_fast 11y agoNot a single mention of Flash! I've got a hunch Windows 10 may popularize it again... Still a more consistent runtime than all the stuff that "killed" it.
- jetskindo 11y agoFlash wasn't the problem entirely. If they fixed the security issues we would be better off. The reason we hated flash is because of how advertisers used it.
- byron_fast 11y agoFlash did solve the problem that the article complains about: consistency of experience and not having to develop your site / app to a pile of different runtimes. But that's not a bug, but a feature for those in the business of selling admission to walled gardens. Same as it ever was.
- dorgo 11y agoMy problem with flash is the same as with all plugins: scroll doesnt work, mouse-gesture dont work, shortcuts dont work, no control of content. Its like opening an enterly other program in browser without any integration.
- puranjay 11y agoWhy are people here attacking The Verge instead of talking about the issue in question? Let's be honest: mobile web is a far crappier experience than the desktop web
- Sanddancer 11y agoBecause the mobile web is putting the magnifying glass to the issues that have been lurking in sites. Most people here have computers and the bandwidth to download a large site in seconds, and needed RAM and drive space to have a large cache. When you get rid of that cache, and you slow down the connection, the Verge is a shitty site on the desktop too.
- sergiotapia 11y agoBecause of the data their website serves, only about 3% of it is actual content. The rest is beacons, and trackers, and ads. It's precious coming from them.
- stephenr 11y ago> Let's be honest: mobile web is a far crappier experience than the desktop web Some websites actually have a better 'mobile' site (either through a dedicated site or through responsive stylesheets) than their desktop site, explicitly because they minimise the amount of noise on the page.
- CmonDev 11y agoLet's be honest: web is crap period. Ever since people came up with the crazy idea that documents can somehow be scripted into applications.
- bobajeff 11y agoI just recently made a comment about how many big sites are maintaining several frontends (when they can barely maintain one) with the mobile site being last behind mobile platforms in terms of priority.
- andreapaiola 11y agoLet me declut that for you http://andreapaiola.name/magpie/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.theverge.com%2F&action=&links=on http://andreapaiola.name/magpie/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.thever...
- perlpimp 11y agothere was a post, a link to TED show that referred to binary applets and how we suppose to think of browser being OS and having a safe environment in it to run small binary networked applets. Javascript was a great expriment and V8 kicks ass and probably best there has been for the browsers - yet model that browser is an app and not OS/Kernel with safe place to run privilged code - I think little will change. Because phones still have too little battery to waste and approach to mobile web that it is a browser and not Kernel or a part of the Kernel, little will change. Apple has something - their stuff is binary. Android is all Java so there is that barrier beyond getting closer to hardware. Yes I know JVM is pretty fast and there is JIT. But it is not binary. IMHO
- Sanddancer 11y agoAndroid 5 has gotten rid of JIT, and does AOT compilation of bytecode via libart, and thus runs native code.
- jetskindo 11y agoI stopped reading half way. The mobile Web is amazing. The verge is the kind of website that is broken both on desktop and mobile. And unfortunately there are too many websites like those.
- jay_kyburz 11y agoYou know, people call me crazy, but I build my website for mobile first, and stop there. I kind of like a narrow 480px columns even on desktop.
- liviu 11y agoI read some answers on this article in the past weeks. Some interesting links: http://blog.lmorchard.com/2015/07/22/the-verge-web-sucks/ http://blog.lmorchard.com/2015/07/22/the-verge-web-sucks/ https://twitter.com/satefan/status/623226230301523968 https://twitter.com/satefan/status/623226230301523968
- tempestn 11y agoAs it happens, yesterday I had to stop a well-performing ad campaign on our site, because the banners were simply too bloated. For a good 10 seconds after the page loaded, their ads would be churning away, loading domain after domain, all to ultimately load a single 160x600px image. In an attempt to demonstrate the problem to them, I made a list of all the domains that were being loaded by their ad code. Here they are: a.rfihub.com aa.chango.com ad.360yield.com adadvisor.net ads.ebay.com ads.nexage.com ads.googleapis.com analytics.spongecell.com ap.lijit.com as.chango.com b3.mookie1.com bc.ixiaa.com bh.contextweb.com c1.rfihub.net cc.chango.com cdn-akamai.mookie1.com cdn.spotxchange.com cdn.viglink.com ce.lijit.com choices.truste.com ckm-m.xp1.ru4.com click.sovrn.com clickcdn.sovrn.com clients1.google.com cm.yieldoptimizer.com d.agkn.com d.turn.com dis.criteo.com dm.de.mookie1.com dpm.demdex.net dsum-sec.casalemedia.com dsum.casalemedia.com e.nexac.com edge.quantserve.com ev.ib-ibi.com ewr-128.ewr-rtb1.rfihub.com fbstatic-a.akamaihd.net fei.pro-market.net global.ib-ibi.com gmtdmp.mookie1.com gpush.cogocast.net gslbeacon.lijit.com i.w55c.net ib.mookie1.com idsync.rlcdn.com image2.pubmatic.com js.revsci.net load.s3.amazonaws.com loadm.exelator.com match.adsrvr.org msec.xp1.ru4.com openx2-match.dotomi.com p.rfihub.com pix04.revsci.net pixel.quantserve.com pixel.rubiconproject.com pixel.sitescout.com r.openx.net royale.cdn.spongecell.com rs.gwallet.com rtb.gumgum.com rtd.tubemogul.com secure-us.imrworldwide.com secure.adnxs.com securepubads.g.doubleclick.net simage2.pubmatic.com soma.smaato.net stags.bluekai.com su.addthis.com sync.adap.tv sync.adaptv.advertising.com sync.graph.bluecava.com sync.search.spotxchange.com sync.tidaltv.com t.mookie1.com t4.liverail.com tag.apxlv.com tag.cogocast.net tag.yieldoptimizer.com tags.bluekai.com tapestry.tapad.com tpc.googlesyndication.com uav.tidaltv.com ums.adtechus.com us-ads.openx.net usefb.adsrvr.org vap1iad3.lijit.com vox-static.liverail.com x.bidswitch.net That's ALL to ultimately load one ad. And of course, those are only domains; many of those load multiple resources. Basically what they appear to be doing is "waterfalling" through a massive number of third party networks, looking for the most profitable ads. And it works well, if all you care about is revenue. The user experience is pretty terrible though. Even though the ads are asynchronous, so don't block the rest of the page, that amount of crap obviously slows things down in general, especially on mobile browsers. Plus, it just feels bloated when after the page is done loading, it sits there for 10 seconds with the spinner whirling and random ad domains spamming across the status bar. It's really painful, because this kind of thing works; it outperforms adsense (which is extremely lightweight in comparison) by a significant margin. There's got to be a cost in user retention though, even if your only concern is the bottom line. (Let alone caring about user experience.)
- davidgerard 11y agoAdBlock for Firefox on Android.