2 ms·
Also you have to remember that by 1944-45 the Japanese economy was a smoking ruin. They'd lost all their overseas territories, we were island-hopping up to the
by paulmd 11y ago
Also you have to remember that by 1944-45 the Japanese economy was a smoking ruin. They'd lost all their overseas territories, we were island-hopping up to their doorstep, and firebombing the shit out of their industrial centers in Honshu. They were incapable of manufacturing sufficient quantities of basic war materiel like rifles, and they could only turn out a very limited quantity of high-end manufacturing like the J2M Raiden and the N1K Shiden interceptor aircraft (which were an known quantity, let alone developing new heavy-bomber type engines like that). Most of that critical production had actually been moved into caves to keep it safe from the firebombing. That's how fucked they were.
The idea of them pulling off a Manhattan Project-scale effort - even if they knew exactly what to do - is utterly preposterous. You'd be talking about a very large-scale effort that utilized a great deal of rare resources, energy, and scientific+high-end engineering capacity and it's utterly implausible even if they abandoned everything else. Let alone being able to effectively deliver it in anything except a tactical attack. No heavy bombers, no carrier fleet, no overseas bases? Not gonna happen. Best case is you sneak it into a west-coast harbor with a long-range sub on a one-way trip (if there's one thing that could have made us angrier than Pearl Harbor...). Most likely case you blow it retaking some random island. Worst case, well, they did kinda have the suicide cult thing going on.
Now that said they were clearly doing basic research/groundwork on the topic, even if they didn't have the capability to execute mass production or an effective attack. The general concepts of fission were pretty well known even pre-war - it was more of an industrial problem than a conceptual one, in the sense that they would have had to figure out the exact rates/constants involved in fission and the exact technologies/designs needed to cause effective fission, figure out the purification/refining processes and scale them up. The specifics weren't known, but pre-war physicists pretty much understood how to build an atom bomb in principle, looooong before they got their hands on workable quantities of material. Otherwise the US never would have devoted that quantity of expertise and resources.