7 ms·
Leaked Uber financials from 2012 to 2014
- icpmacdo 11y agoI dont think Uber is going anywhere soon. It has such a strong brand. Everyone I know trusts uber a lot more than there local cab companies.
- puranjay 11y agoI do wonder what will happen once Uber starts charging market rates. Right now, your ride is subsidized by Uber. Once it comes time to turn on the profits, you'll have to pay more - substantially more in some markets. Will you still use Uber? Probably. But many who started using Uber instead of, say, taking their own car or using public transport, just might go back.
- everly 11y agoI suspect that the data they possess on usage rate during surge pricing will be extremely useful for making those projections.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes it should be possible to modelled this out from the surge data. Of course you have to be careful doing this sort of modelling since you might find your model won’t support a $50 billion valuation.
- venomsnake 11y agoNo it should not. Because surge pricing requires supply crunch. But the moment they jack day to day prices you will have supply glut. And creating an Uber like app for just one city is not that hard.
- danieltillett 11y agoSurge pricing allows you to model the price elasticity of the service. You can do all sorts of experiments and regression analysis on this data. If I had access to the data I could tell you exactly how elastic the pricing is. The problem is not that you can't extract the price elasticity from the surge pricing of an Uber-like service, it is that you might not like the answer. Down rounds are not nice to founders.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis is actually something that is pretty straightforward to find out (assuming you actual want to know the answer). You just jack up the prices in a single market and see how much price elasticity there is. My feeling is that the taxi-like market is a commodity market, but if I was going to invest at a $50 billion valuation I would want Uber to tell me that have looked into this in detail and can provide me with some hard data.
- aikah 11y ago> I do wonder what will happen once Uber starts charging market rates. That's an excellent question and the answer is it wont be cheap. That's why, in countries where Uber operates, a clear legal framework is needed so that Uber doesn't end up with a monopoly. If Uber is allowed to operate somewhere then anybody should be able to do that without the need for an army of lawyers and lobbyists or it's just replacing the old boss with a new boss and in the end nothing's going to change for the consumer. That's what I hate with the whole situation.
- sbank 11y agoPrivate monopolies are largely unproblematic as they will be destroyed by more effective competitors eventually. I'm way more afraid of government monopoly. Point in case: The protectionism and government interference that has kept the taxi business shitty for so long.
- wfo 11y agoPrivate monopolies are in some theoretical circumstances unproblematic because according to extremist free-market ideologues they are destroyed by more effective competitors. In reality they are broken up by governments, regulated into the ground, or destroy a nation/society, and they manage to make a society/market a whole lot worse before this long-term and extreme regulatory action obliterates them and fixes the problem.
- puranjay 11y ago> they manage to make a society/market a whole lot worse I can imagine this argument holding true for resource-based businesses, say, oil and gas. I can't imagine a taxi services aggregator having that substantial an impact on a nation
- wfo 11y agoYou're right the argument is less strong for a non-natural monopoly, but Microsoft, say, when they had a monopoly, held back computing by years and we're still seeing the aftereffects of their monopoly; it has warped an entire industry in not only the US but the world.
- morgante 11y ago> I do wonder what will happen once Uber starts charging market rates. Right now, your ride is subsidized by Uber. Do you have any evidence of that? I'm 99% sure Uber is profitable on a unit and customer basis.
- krrrh 11y agoThere is evidence of this all over the press if you want to search for it. Take for instance The 'non-profit' "People's Uber" in China. They guaranteed wages for drivers and capped rates at auto rickshaw prices. This spring in Guangzhou I was taking 20 minute rides and paying around $1.50. It was ridiculous. While they were trying to maintain a foothold in Germany as more than a legal taxi hailing service (which is what they are now, competing with apps like mytaxi) they were limiting prices to legal Mitfahrgelegenheit (private ride share) prices. What was normally a 70€ cab ride between Düsseldorf and Köln cost 12€ (Less than taking the regional train for 1 person though the driver was paid much more of course. This went on for months. I'm sure they are making money in markets where the existing taxi service was truly dreadful and where they don't have to compete on price and have been able to raise their rates to on par or higher than taxi rates, but they are definitely paying a price for expansion.
- morgante 11y ago> they are definitely paying a price for expansion. Of course, that's the whole reason to raise capital (so you can expand rapidly on a model which has attractive unit economics). The point is that we don't have to speculate about what will happen once Uber raises prices. Just look at their mature markets, where pricing is on par with taxis, and you can see a profitable model.
- krrrh 11y agoI think that the profitability in mature markets has a lot to do with how sane existing taxi regulations are. Even with the subsidized prices in Berlin, taxis there are so plentiful and relatively affordable that aside from heavily subsidized rides Uber didn't have a huge edge over the taxi+mytaxi combo. It was never really faster to get a car via Uber than with MyTaxi, or more often than not, just walking to the street and waiting 1-2 minutes. They've never had close to the same participation from Taxi drivers as MyTaxi and others have had. Incidentally, most Berlin Taxis are independent and pay only a small fee to get licensed. They must carry commercial insurance, but almost no one thinks that is unreasonable. It's ironic because if the cities where Uber is madly profitable actually responded to their criticisms and reformed their protectionist taxi regulations, Uber would lose much of their pricing edge to competition.
- danielweber 11y agoUber is making money off of each ride. "Money they charge the end user" minus "money they pay to the driver" is a value that increases significantly each quarter. They have a bunch of other expenses, but those are expected to lessen in the future. Training (of both customers and drivers) should fall to near-zero, for example, over time.
- scurvy 11y agoThat's odd to me. Everyone I know thinks that Uber is shady and uses Lyft. Very people use Flywheel in SF as it just gets you a cab. But at least a cab driver (generally) knows where they're going, rather than relying on GPS because they're from the East Bay and don't know the city at all. Uber's app history of tracking people is also not great. I use Lyft when I can. Last time I used Uber was in New Orleans, and even then I used the mobile web version.
- prostoalex 11y agoThe competition would likely be smaller competitors chipping away at juicy chunks, like Wingz focusing exclusively on airport rides (and competing with UberX on price) and Blacklane promising higher level of service at cheaper rate than Uber Black.
- andyidsinga 11y agoyep ...if it gets as easy to bootstrap a ride sharing company it is for chat apps with the mobile address book competition might be tough on uber. see also http://continuations.com/post/77698925932/facebook-massively-overpaid-for-whatsapp http://continuations.com/post/77698925932/facebook-massively...
- ismail 11y agoThat post is missing the network effects. Put another way switching costs are high not because it is easy to bootstrap these but the fact that to switch, your entire social circle would need to switch around the same time. It is no use half switching, if you have an app which has 50% of your friends and another with 100% which will you use? * that for every person and your retention drops and you end up with a feedback loop which is negative(churn) instead of positive (growth). Now with Uber the switching costs are low (currently), you can just as easily request a lyft and drivers can use both apps. The long term play of uber though will make it difficult for others to compete since network effects will kick in. If you have more passengers and drivers, it makes it that much easier for you to do real ridesharing I. E 2-3 people per a car driving down costs. Once you add additional revenue streams like last mile delivery + passengers + ondemand x and I can see why they are investing this much in owning the market.
- andyidsinga 11y agoI thought the whole point (of the post) was the network effects can effectively be bootstrapped from the mobile phone book. if all drivers (who aren't uber employees) and all users can be part of multiple networks (bootstrapped from mobile phonebook and almost zero cost to both) how can uber maintain a dominant position?
- jfoster 11y agoYeah, I just tested myself: can I name any of the prominent taxi companies in Sydney (where I live)? Maybe; is Silver Service the name of one, or is it a type of taxi? I'm not sure, but it's the only one that comes to mind.
- bsder 11y agoThe real question is: do you care? I personally don't care which taxi company carries me on my journey.
- jfoster 11y agoThat's probably the reason why I don't know the brands. I don't care; they're all about the same. I think icpmacdo's comment stands, though. Uber have built an amazingly strong brand that people do care about. To the point where I am willing to wait a few minutes for an UberX to reach me rather than hailing one of the taxis passing by. Even though UberX is a bit inconsistent in quality, it is at least consistently better than taxis.
- mootothemax 11y agoI dont think Uber is going anywhere soon. It has such a strong brand. Everyone I know trusts uber a lot more than there local cab companies. They seem to be following the same pattern as large supermarkets: - Move into an unserved area - Offer goods/services at rock-bottom prices - As competition reduces, increase prices and squeeze suppliers - Profit, profit, profit! An interesting example of this is Tesco (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesco), who at one point were receiving one pound in seven spent in the UK. According to the wiki, that's now widened to one in every ten pounds. The other interesting angle is that Tesco have been hugely profitable until this year, when they reported a loss of nearly six billion pounds. We'll have to see what happens next.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rtpg 11y agoWait, so Uber spent $900 million dollars? I thought that considering they offload so much of the costs of running of the business( EDIT: through having drivers buy the cars, for example), they wouldn't have such high operating costs. Though according to this[1] article, Uber's at 3000 employees worldwide. What are those employees doing? EDIT: For reference, Greyhound's 2014 operating costs were 600 million pounds (50 million in profit). [1] http://techcrunch.com/2015/05/28/uber-new-hq/#.bb69xm:poPo http://techcrunch.com/2015/05/28/uber-new-hq/#.bb69xm:poPo
- austenallred 11y agoDespite popular belief, apps and communities don't run themselves. Uber is scaling at an ungodly speed, and they're hiring a ton of people to do so. Seriously, look at how many jobs they're hiring for right now: https://www.uber.com/jobs/list https://www.uber.com/jobs/list (then realize they're doing this in hundreds of cities simultaneously, in addition to the hundreds they're already in). I'm actually blown away that they're losing so little, given the amount of revenue they're bringing in. Those are, despite what it may seem, really good numbers. If they can reach scale and capture the market (not trivial)... wow.
- rtpg 11y ago1200 job openings... that's impressive. I agree that you need people to expand, but it never hurts to question how many people you actually need. Nobody denies that megacorps probably have many redundant positions, it's not possible for a company with 3000 employees to have them either.
- austenallred 11y agoMy understanding from talking with people close to the company is that they have a process for opening one city. It's a specific number of people in exact positions (15, if I remember correctly)? They go out and clone the exact process/number of people in each new city. It starts with one person who is responsible for spearheading the operation; that person is supposed to find, hire, and manage the other 14. It's like Uber is opening up franchises of itself. The model has been nailed, so it's just a matter of cloning/duplicating that model. I'm not certain on all of the details, but I find it absolutely fascinating.
- empressplay 11y agoSo what's the model? Put the taxis out of business and then jack up the fares to what the taxis were? Who's winning, then, exactly? Not the consumer...
- danieltillett 11y agoIn theory if they can lower the costs substantially through innovation over the current taxi model they can grow the market out of private car usage. This would mean all parties (except car manufacturers) will benefit.
- friendzis 11y agoIn transportation business major costs are vehicle depreciation/maintenance/consumables (fuel, insurance, tires, etc), wages and you can include domain specific expenses (insurance, driver health chek-ups). * You can't reduce DS expenses. You can offload them to drivers, but that will still be reflected in prices * You can reduce wage cost by eliminating administrative load by having tools (apps, backends) do the job. Considering the size of Uber they are just transfering wages from operators to engineers. * You can't reduce wehicle depreciation. You can reduce maintenance costs by having own workshop. Taxi companies might have that, for Uber that would be next to impossible due to practical reasons. You can reduce operating costs by buying fuel/insurance/etc in bulk. Agin, easy for cabs, difficult for Uber (not impossible though). The only place I see Uber can compete is having innovative algorithms route the cars by adjusting for projected demand. Unless they have huge army of dedicated drivers, drivers driving for multiple companies kind of defeats that advantage. currently Uber does compete by exploiting legal frameworks and not labeling their drivers as professionals and their service as transportation. This is not a major factor in operating costs though.
- prostoalex 11y agoI am not sure how much of an edge one can gain by doing demand prediction through algorithms. In large markets the patterns are fairly trivial (big game ended, everybody goes home; it's 5 pm in financial district, people are leaving work; busy time at the airport, bunch of flights arriving at once) and known to all participants.
- dpflan 11y agoUber is certainly aggressive and maintains their attitude throughout. I would like to see Lyft's financials compared to Uber's considering Uber's global dominance target and Lyft's decision to focus on US domestic [1]. Source: [1.] http://www.mercurynews.com/business/ci_28566633/lyft-forgoes-global-expansion-favor-u-s-market http://www.mercurynews.com/business/ci_28566633/lyft-forgoes...
- joshjkim 11y agoBasic rundown of Rev / Loss from reports: Q1.12: 1.4M / 3.4M Q2.12: 2.1M /2.3M Q3.12: 4.3M / 5.4M Q4.12: 8.2M / 7.0M Q1.13: 12.9M / 7.3M Q2.13: 19.3M / 8.1M 2013 (total): 104M / 56M Q1.14: 45.6M / 52.2M Q2.13: 56.9M / 108.8M Rev grew faster than losses consistently all through 2012 and 2013 which is really amazing (2013 is when Uber jumped from a 330M valuation to a 3.5B valuation so investors noticed too)...then losses abruptly charged ahead in 2014 (see data pulled below). Uber launched China in Q1 of 2014 - they are basically betting huge on China / India, and smartly being very clear to their investors that the $$ is for that very costly cause, so they can earmark the cash they are burning for international expansion as "meant to be burned." Also, if the bet goes the wrong way, they can (sort of) cleanly write it off as a failed (billion dollar) project, and ask investors to focus on their (hopefully by then) cash-cow business in the US. Burn is all about international expansion, which is SUPER expensive, especially at the rate they are attempting. There is an insane learning curve that costs a lot of money to get on the other side of (hiring, culture, regulations, consumers, marketing are all different in each country - not to mention the fact that local competitors have all those in line already!) - look at pretty much any major US company that has attempted to succeed in China. Good luck!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- andygates 11y agoSo what happens when they've aggressively expanded into all their target markets and are still not profitable and have nowhere else to go? Pure expansion is pretty much the sign of a first-mover bubble company who will collapse with their advantage being copied by calmer second-movers...
- yummyfajitas 11y agoExpansion costs money, running operations is cheaper. So when growth stops, profit happens almost by default. Simple math. Suppose opening a city costs $10 (once) and returns $1/year in revenue. Year 1: Open 1 city, loss = $10. Year 2: Open 3 cities, loss = $29 (spending $30 on new cities, gaining $1 from year 1's city). Year 3: Open 9 cities, loss = $86. Year 4: expansion stops, profit = $13.
- Animats 11y agoAs the article points out, the real question is whether Uber is making money in mature markets, such as San Francisco. If the mature markets aren't highly profitable, Uber is way overvalued.
- the_economist 11y agoThey make 20% of every ride. What costs do they really have in a mature market? A bit of customer service and maintaining the app. I don't see how it could possibly do anything but print cash in mature markets.
- untog 11y agoDrivers won't be Uber drivers forever - they'll need to keep pushing to hire new drivers to replace ones that drop out. And don't write off customer service - it is expensive.
- philfrasty 11y ago"leaked"
- kfk 11y agoWhat is interesting is that those volumes put Uber no where close to a monopoly player in the taxi/"car lifts" market. They are just 1 player and I think people use them because their app is cooler than calling a taxi by phone or razing your hand. I don't know, I wouldn't put money on them. Maybe their app, who knows, could be useful for taxis once uber goes away?
- coldcode 11y agoUltimately Uber wants to corner the market on providing automated cars. Having drivers is just the stepping stone. If you are synonymous with providing rides then when automated transportation is available, everything thinks of you.
- zekevermillion 11y agoOf course, Uber could hunker down in one market and start making a profit. But they are trying to form a global monopoly in all the major urban markets. New capital is going to dry up pretty soon unless they are prepared to go public. Either Uber has to lower its sights to limited regional domination, or it has to go public. Given their MO I would think they are preparing for the latter option.
- curiousjorge 11y agoI think Uber thinks lighting piles of cash on fire is somehow a competitive edge builder, when the more money they burn faster, the bigger the return they need to make on a razor thin margin, zero barrier to entry market with no network effects. As soon as they've knocked down the walls of regulation and stretched out thin and begin to make any profit at all, it will signal other new entrants. The newer entrants are more likely to succeed thanks to the road that has been paved by Uber. Uber's solution: burn more money acquiring unprofitable new market threats if they miraculously make enough cash if they get another boatload of naive investors. Afterall, Uber does not own the cars or drivers. As soon as somebody else is willing to give them a better cut or or they are able to get more money per customer, they will always go there. tl;dr: Uber has absolutely no sustainable long-term economic moat built around it and lighting cash on fire may drive current competitors out, it will not work as soon as they attempt to recoup those costs (profit signals market entrants, uber does not own drivers, cars, or customers due to zero cost of switching - it's just a fucking app).
- ismail 11y agoNote: we built a rideshare matching system so this is from my experience single person with 1 car has no network effect. 1+ passengers does. See my post above.