2 ms·
I don’t have anything against children’s books; I love children’s books! If the goal is to fit 2 sentences on a page with a big picture and individual letters t
by jacobolus 11y ago
I don’t have anything against children’s books; I love children’s books! If the goal is to fit 2 sentences on a page with a big picture and individual letters that are easy to discriminate to help when just learning to read, then large text is a perfectly reasonable part of the design. Large widely spaced text is just not necessarily appropriate for other types of material, where fitting more text on the screen is an important design feature.
This is especially relevant when we’re talking about Edward Tufte: Tufte devotes a huge portion of his books to emphasizing that information presentation is improved when more information is presented in a smaller space, to facilitate references and comparisons between different items/sections. “Information wants to be spatially adjacent so as facilitate comparisons made within the common eyespan of the viewer.”
As a concrete comparison, here’s what fits in my browser view in this “Tufte CSS” document:
http://imgur.com/iLNgoaU http://imgur.com/iLNgoaU
Here’s what fits on a page in an Edward Tufte book:
http://imgur.com/dTLcDx2 http://imgur.com/dTLcDx2
- gabemart 11y agoThis is where portrait-orientated displays excel: http://i.imgur.com/D9MfvQN.png http://i.imgur.com/D9MfvQN.png
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoThis will obviously depend upon what device you're using, but hold a book up in front of you at about the distance you would typically read it (this should be MUCH closer than your screen!). Now compare the size of the text (admittedly, this is tricky because of focus, but it's just about possible) - the font size in the example is pretty much exactly the same as in a typical book, for me at least. Designers have, for a long time, thought that 'small text is cool/looks better' but there has been a pushback on this by web designers over the past few years. Maybe even HN will one day update its styles for readability; at least a shorter line-length/larger leading would be a great start.