4 ms·
In what way is it terrifying to analyze the hugely controversial deployment of a terrible weapon against a civilian population, and the post-hoc justifications
by the_af 11y ago
In what way is it terrifying to analyze the hugely controversial deployment of a terrible weapon against a civilian population, and the post-hoc justifications for this act?
This is not science. This is war and recent history, which are political beasts by nature. This was the deployment of a terrifying strategic weapon, which has doubly political implications. Any piece of journalism or recent news related to this -- either justifying or decrying this horrific historical event -- must be closely scrutinized by everyone interested in the subject matter.
If tomorrow a piece of news reads "secret documents have been uncovered which prove conclusively and decisively that the dropping of the atom bomb was done only to scare the Soviets and had no relation to the actual threat posed by the Japanese army, and the government and high command was aware of this, and here is a secret recording that proves it once and for all" this would also merit close scrutiny: why are they saying this now? Why near this date? Who benefits from this interpretation? Who doesn't? Is there any way this alleged recording could have been taken out of context or faked? Will the current military be similarly willing to deploy nuclear weapons against cities to impress other world powers, or have modern attitudes changed?
If this doesn't merit close scrutiny, what does?
- brighteyes 11y agoOf course I agree we should debate that very important topic. No objection to that. What I find worrying is that sandworm takes a quite objective piece of reporting - a news article, not an opinion piece - and begins immediately to make assumptions about the author's politics, and to find grievous fault in those politics. He or she jumps straight to attacking the author and their motives, instead of considering what they are saying. sandworm doesn't even find anything not objective in the article. His or her complaints amounts to "the author presents evidence that, while true, is clearly meant to argue such-and-such specific political point of view, and they are terrible people for promoting that agenda." The article is just an interesting piece on new evidence. Sure, it could in theory be used to argue for some political side (more than one in fact), but no one actually did that, except in sandworm's head. If we lose the ability to have objective discussions about history, facts, and science, we lose as a society.