3 ms·
I would argue that plutonium breeding is only obvious after you have performed some criticality experiments with an appreciable-sized block of enriched uranium.
by sandworm101 11y ago
I would argue that plutonium breeding is only obvious after you have performed some criticality experiments with an appreciable-sized block of enriched uranium. This was new physics at the time, without computer simulations. Bomb theory, critical mass, could only be understood after you get your hands on some enriched uranium.
- hga 11y agoIndeed, but there's a chick and egg problem there. We put the plutonium process fully in gear before we even knew the average number of neutrons a Pu-239 fast fission would produce, when we had no more than micrograms or so of cyclotron produced stuff. Which was enough to work out the separation chemistry, ultra-microchemisty is amazing. I guess my point here is that the Germans realized uranium separation was a no-go for them, were trying reactor based approaches, and they might have rolled the dice that way and tried the plutonium path. I'm saying the pieces were in play to possible success, not that it was at all likely without 20/20 hindsight.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoThis is very much not the case. Bomb theory and critical mass come from a fundamental understanding of neutron chain reactions. You need to have good data on fission properties and neutron mean-free-path distances, but that requires only extremely tiny amounts of Plutonium or natural Uranium, it does not require enriched Uranium. Other than that the other critical factor is coming up with the correct model/theory for nuclear weapons. Something that the Japanese got right, the Americans and British got right, and the Germans (specifically Heisenberg) ended up getting extremely wrong. Fine tuning critical mass calculations was important in optimizing the bomb later on but it wasn't necessary to developing the basic underlying theory of how bombs work or of pointing the way toward implosion assembly and Plutonium breeding.