14 ms·
MH370: Reunion debris is from missing plane
- JanSolo 11y agoNot really a huge surprise given that the debris was confirmed as a 777 flaperon a few days ago. However, It does mean that the Inmarsat positional analysis about the final location of the plane is likely correct. This should give a bit of confidence to the sailors who are running the naval search operation in the indian ocean. They were never quite sure that they were looking in the right place. I suspect their lack-of-results must be quite demoralising for them. It also discounts some of the nuttier theories such as the plane landing in Russia or Afghanistan.
- muglug 11y agoUnless (puts on tinfoil hat) that piece of wreckage was placed there with the intent that it would be discovered. Nutty people will believe whatever they want.
- hencq 11y ago> It does mean that the Inmarsat positional analysis about the final location of the plane is likely correct. Does it though? I'm not saying the analysis is incorrect, just wondering how predictable these ocean currents are. I understand that the debris surfacing at Reunion doesn't rule out the current search location, but that's different than confirming or proving it. I mean, can they just 'play back' the ocean currents and arrive at a specific spot? I wouldn't be surprised if there's so much uncertainty that all they can say with certainty is that it must have crashed somewhere in the Indian Ocean. Which isn't exactly new information.
- mikeash 11y agoThe Inmarsat data seems pretty solid, but it's not very precise. There was always the possibility that the plane actually went down somewhere on the northern arc, rather than the southern arc as was assumed. The northern arc was never very likely because the plane would almost certainly have been noticed on that path, but this debris finding rules it out entirely. (In case anyone is unfamiliar with just what the data showed, here's a quick summary image: http://ogleearth.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/MH370_Mar17.jpg http://ogleearth.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/MH370_Mar17....)
- acqq 11y agoNo, it was actually possible to exclude the northern arc based on the satellite data only: http://www.airtrafficmanagement.net/2014/06/mh370-what-does-inmarsat-ping-data-reveal/ http://www.airtrafficmanagement.net/2014/06/mh370-what-does-... "the Doppler shift due to the satellite’s motion is not removed by the plane’s terminal when it pre-corrects the frequency of transmission, and thus there is an asymmetry between the BFO which would be produced by a plane flying north of the equator (and thus situated to the north of the satellite) compared to one flying south on a similar track."
- mikeash 11y agoNice! Never heard that stuff. I stand corrected.
- acqq 11y agoIt's a perfect example for "science, it works." They managed to conclude quite a lot from a miniscule amount of data with the information that was never planned to be used for such purposes.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoSadly, people will attempt to overthink that. E.g. jeffwise.net was cited earlier as a forum discussing AF447. But read this from Jeff concerning the Inmarsat data: case 3. The plane did not go south at all. If this is the case, then the satellite communications system must have been compromised by hijackers who either flew the plane north to Kazakhstan or China (if only the BFO values were spoofed) or somewhere else within a huge circle encompassed by the 7th ping ring (if both BTO and BFO values were spoofed). Yes, it's possible that occurred. But even Inmarsat itself didn't have a good understanding of this data. It's very very farfetched to think that some sinister elements, as part of a nefarious scheme, spoofed the data being sent to the satellite. IMO the probability is less than 1 in a million. So many other scenarios make more sense.
- rogerbinns 11y agoThe satellite position analysis only says where the plane likely was near the end of its flight. How it ended up in the water matters greatly. For example if there was someone conscious in the cockpit then it could have glided way outside of the search area. Even an uncontrolled spiralling into the ocean describes a potentially large area. One thing that keeps resurfacing is that the whole affair is unlike anything before. Suicidal pilots have crashed quickly in all other cases, various things have involved extraordinary good luck or extraordinary knowledge (eg avoiding various radar coverage), explanations for satellite systems going offline/online require precise fiddling with various electrical busses, there aren't any credible explanations for deliberate act or accident, the Malaysian government has either covered things up or is very incompetent (or both), and it goes on. Air France 440 was also shrouded in mystery (but nowhere near this degree), and turned out to be very poor airmanship by one pilot. For anyone curious about more of the technical aspects behind the scenes then Jeff Wise writes about it frequently. http://jeffwise.net/ http://jeffwise.net/
- gnaffle 11y ago> Air France 440 was also shrouded in mystery (but nowhere near this degree), and turned out to be very poor airmanship by one pilot. It was poor airmanship by two pilots (and other factors, including the feedback mechanisms and the lack of training for this particular high altitude scenario).
- encoderer 11y agoMy understanding is that the pilot in the left chair didn't realize that the pilot in the right chair kept pulling his stick back. In boeing planes, the sticks move together, so that wouldn't be possible. And the pilot in the right chair clearly didn't understand that in the alternate law the fly by wire system was running in, his stick movements put the plane at risk.
- mikeash 11y agoYes, it was a completely incorrect reaction by a single pilot, combined with a catastrophically bad design for the controls, which caused that crash. It is completely insane to me that anyone would think that averaging inputs from two pilots and providing no feedback would be even remotely a good idea.
- elorant 11y agoBut did the plane crash on the ocean or it was shattered mid-air? Wouldn’t the debris be deformed if it had hit the water?
- oh_teh_meows 11y agoHow would one go about verifying that the debris comes from the missing plane, assuming plane-specific serial number is not found? Any expert care to shed some light on this?
- sschueller 11y agoEvery part in a modern airplane has a number. Even the smallest piece. These numbers are recorded and tracked during maintenance.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThe idea that "everything has a part number" is generally correct but has a few exceptions. You won't find serial numbers (or often, part numbers) on small consumables, like washers, or things like rivets. But it's very common for bolts to have part numbers. Something as large as a flaperon would definitely have a part number (which would tell you if it was part of a larger assembly), and might be serialized and directly trackable. Disclosure: I don't work on commercial aircraft, but I do work on military aircraft.
- kejaed 11y agoAny part more complicated than a screw or rivet likely has a serial number / part number on it, and if it does, could be traced back to the exact aircraft it was installed on.
- engi_nerd 11y agoYes. On the aircraft I work on, serial numbers often contain a few digits that are aircraft specific.
- ptaipale 11y agoAnd even if there are no serial numbers, there are detailed maintenance records for the aircraft; you can see if a bolt has been replaced, trimmer adjusted or a hole fixed, and you'll find matching records in the books.
- comrade1 11y agoI at first believed it came from MH370 but now that I hear the Malaysian PM confirm it it makes me wonder if it's from some other source. (This is a sarcastic comment on the quality of thee Malaysian leadership and how they handled the situation.)
- JanSolo 11y agoI'm sure the PM is overjoyed that this story kicked up again right now. Anything that distracts the press from his embezzlement scandal is likely very welcome.
- ptaipale 11y agoThe funny thing is that the PM also put out an arrest warrant for a British journalist (Gordon Brown's sister-in-law) for covering the corruption case. If he hadn't done that, I wouldn't have heard of his whole scandal before this.
- agumonkey 11y agoSo currents pushed debris toward Reunion, but is it possible that things drifted non linearly and scattered everywhere or will they be able to find the remains in a short time now ?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoThere is an image at the bottom of the article which shows simulated debris movement over time. According to that, the stuff could be spread in a wide band from Madagascar to Tasmania by now.
- Someone 11y agoEven if a) currents and winds where 100% known and b) we could perfectly compute how they interact with objects, the parts still could end up in widely different places. Different parts will have had different starting positions (even a few meters can make a huge difference. The part found made it to Reunion, but if it had floated a few meters further, it might have missed the Island and, over time, float hundreds of more miles, or it might have landed on an island that it now completely missed) Also, the shape, weight, etc. of pieces affects where they float; a mostly submerged part will not see much impact from wind, a sailboat-like part will see lots of impact from it. Even identical pieces may float in different directions if they end up in the water at different orientations. http://oceanmotion.org/html/research/ebbesmeyer.htm http://oceanmotion.org/html/research/ebbesmeyer.htm: "Knowing the paths of the currents, though, is not enough. Other factors such as shape, size, and buoyancy may also determine an object’s course. Curt has observed with fascination that different beaches specialize in different types of debris. One beach may collect light bulbs while another collects tennis balls. Even right and left sneakers end up in different places"
- Ocerge 11y agoI imagine some fascinating papers will come out soon from people who will do the math/simulations to hone in on a tighter search area than what the Inmersat data has given us.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoOne thing is bugging me in all this: Is this a part that should float?
- mullen 11y agoYes. It is a completely sealed part and is designed to float. Why it is designed that way, I don't know.
- chrismarlow9 11y agoMaybe so it can be found in the event of a crash :D
- Gracana 11y agoProbably it is just designed to not get water inside it (wouldn't want your wings filling with water while flying), so it happens to float.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoAh, yes. Rain should not cause the wings to fill up with water...
- curtis 11y agoOne thing that is not clear to me is if this part is mostly aluminum or mostly carbon fiber. If it's carbon fiber, the fact that it can float might not be so surprising. Another interesting question is just how high it was floating in the water. If it just barely reached the surface then it would experience very little windage, so its path through the ocean would be almost entire driven by currents. I don't know that that would simplify drift analysis, but it seems like it might.
- 0xffff2 11y agoAre any parts on the 777 carbon fiber? I was under the impression that composite parts were a very new thing on commercial jetliners, significantly post-dating the design of the 777.
- swasheck 11y agoOfficially, it's a "very strong presumption" and has not been officially confirmed. Apparently there are some things that don't add up for the U.S. NTSB. "A person involved in the investigation said, however, that experts from Boeing and the National Transportation Safety Board who have seen the object — a piece of what is known as a flaperon — were not yet fully satisfied, and called for further analysis. Their doubts were based on a modification to the flaperon part that did not appear to exactly match what they would expect from airline maintenance records, according to the person, who was not authorized to discuss the matter publicly and requested anonymity." http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/06/world/asia/mh370-wing-reunion.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/06/world/asia/mh370-wing-reun... Still, hopefully it turns out to be officially and conclusively confirmed so that the process of closure can begin for the families.
- blakeyrat 11y agoThere aren't any other missing 777's, so all they really need is to conclusively determine the part came from a 777 and process of elimination takes care of the rest. Still, I understand them wanting to be extremely cautious.
- MichaelGG 11y agoWell, not quite, right? If you wanna be paranoid, it could be a maintenance/replacement part from another 777, deliberately planted. (Not that I believe that's likely, just saying.)
- engi_nerd 11y agoTo be definitive, though, you need to find evidence that proves that the piece you found was present on the aircraft for the flight where it went missing. You have to have some way to say, "Ah, yes, this flaperon is a Boeing part number, with serial number #XXXXXX. Maintenance records show that this exact serial number was installed on the aircraft in question, and its configuration as found matches the configuration of record for this part on the aircraft in question." Then you know for sure to a degree that will stand up in any inquiry.
- 11y ago