6 ms·
I wouldn’t use the phase "attempt to build the bomb". I wouldn't even call this an effort. I would label this as discussion or thought experiments. Drawing u
by sandworm101 11y ago
I wouldn’t use the phase "attempt to build the bomb". I wouldn't even call this an effort.
I would label this as discussion or thought experiments. Drawing up a few blueprints for a centrifuge is no more an attempt to build a bomb than Project Daeidalus was an "attempt" to travel to another star. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus. The amount of effort necessary to build bombs during the 40s was ridiculous. Japan didn't have the industrial power. And I mean literal power as the manhatten project's Oak Ridge facility used something like 1/8th of US electricity at the time.
"Electric energy consumption, courtesy of the TVA, was 20 percent higher than that of New York City. Oak Ridge used one-seventh of all the electricity produced in the United States" http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1652.html http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1652.html (not the best source, but reasonable given the context.)
I'm all for discussion of ALL history but to bring forward claims that Japan was trying to build a bomb so close to the anniversary of its use against Japan smacks of guilt-motivated justification. Japan's "bomb" program was of absolutely no threat to allied forces and therefore should not be part of any debate over the use of nuclear weapons against Japan. If anything, a Japanese bomb program would have sucked up resources from other war efforts.
- brighteyes 11y agoFirst, it was certainly an effort. They had centrifuges, attempts to gather enough uranium, and so forth. That is more than "discussion" and "thought experiments" as you call it. Also, I see no point to your ad hominem attack that the article "smacks of guilt-motivated justification". The article presents interesting historical facts, and I don't see it suggesting that dropping the bomb on Japan was justified. Finally, was the Japanese effort to produce a bomb likely to succeed? In retrospect, we know it was definitely not. But you seem, in addition, to be very confident that they knew that fact at the time. Do you have a source for that?
- sandworm101 11y ago(1) Research centrifuges for separating isotopes and a plant capable of creating enough for a bomb are different beasts. The former gives you the knowledge to understand the scope of the later. (2) I don't attack only the article itself, but also its timing in relation to the anniversary. Americans are questioning the actions of their fathers and grandfathers re Japan and WWII. Any opinionated or politicized articles appearing now must be judged in that context. (3) The article ends with the quote "If we'd built the bomb first, of course we would have used it. I'm glad, in some ways, that our facilities were destroyed." That quote is meant to leave the reader with the concept that Japan would have done the same as the US had the situation been reversed. Even more so, it suggests that at least one person in Japan welcomed the bombings. Those are justification arguments that, given the enormity of the context and timing, should be strictly scrutinized.
- brighteyes 11y ago1. Even research centrifuges are a lot more than "discussion" or a "thought experiment", the terms that you proposed. Perhaps "research" is a good word for the stage they were in? 2. You're attacking the timing, but the timing makes sense. People are much more interested in the topic now, so it makes sense to publish it now. 3. You seem very eager to guess at the political motivations of the article's author, but not everything is about politics. The quote definitely gets the readers thinking, but (assuming it is accurate, of course) it seems very appropriate for the end of the article. Articles often end on an open question, and it is fascinating to think of what could have happened had history gone differently.
- 13thLetter 11y ago"That quote is meant to leave the reader with the concept that Japan would have done the same as the US had the situation been reversed." Do you think they would _not_ have used atomic bombs, if they had them and believed it was militarily necessary? After all, Japan was not exactly known for merciful treatment of civilian populations or opposing enemy forces during World War II. "Those are justification arguments that, given the enormity of the context and timing, should be strictly scrutinized." Strictly scrutinized by whom, and to what end? Furthermore, should an article which raises arguments against dropping the bomb be scrutinized just as strictly? If not, why not?
- sandworm101 11y agoYes. Any new articles at this time, particularly ones brining forward new or rarely-seen evidence should be put under a magnifying glass. The use of nukes by the US against japan is a backdrop against which all US military decisions are made today.
- brighteyes 11y agoWhat you're saying is terrifying. You want history and historical debate to be completely politicized, with all authors investigated for having the correct ideological underpinnings. History and science would all grind to a halt if the first thing people would do to every article and paper is to check for political leanings.
- peterfirefly 11y ago> If anything, a Japanese bomb program would have sucked up resources from other war efforts. Yep. That's also why we should be thankful for the V-2.
- Maultasche 11y agoNot only did the V-2 program divert resources from more useful efforts, but the United States got the knowledge (and some unused V-2s) to give their space and missile development a big boost. The first big rockets the US fired were unused V-2 rockets followed by US-built V-2 clones. That program ended up benefiting the United States much more than it did Germany. The nuclear programs of Japan and Germany, however, never got close to producing an atomic bomb, and the research done was mostly useless at the end of the war.
- WalterBright 11y agoOne of Stalin's priorities in invading Germany was capturing intact the German nuclear research facilities. I wonder if that wound up helping the Soviet bomb program significantly.
- kencausey 11y agoYou might enjoy the book Plutopia by Kate Brown.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoThat and his own spies in the Manhattan Project.
- peterfirefly 11y agoThe US got the better rocket scientists/engineers, the USSR got the better nuclear engineers. In particular, they got better centrifuge experts. The better centrifuges are the reason why the USSR could build their bombs so quickly and so much cheaper than the first US bombs. PS: would you consider releasing the source code of one of your very early compilers at some point?
- hga 11y agoEh, the reason we spent so much effort at Oak Ridge is that we tried all vaguely practical methods of getting weapons grade fissionables, and that was the location for uranium enrichment, thermal, caltron, and gaseous diffusion. But the most practical method turned out to be breeding plutonium and separating it, and that was done at Hanford on a vast scale, the largest single WWII construction project. But not inherently super electricity intensive, the piles had to be kept cool, and ... I'm not sure anything was all that power expensive. Ignoring the minor detail that they had 1/166th of the uranium needed for a Hanford style pile, assuming that 1,200 pounds was the first large quantity the might have gotten their hands on ... well, industrially there was no way they could have pulled this method off, we could just barely do it. They couldn't build reliable airplane engines with > ~1,000 hp of output. Niels Bohr dismissed the concept of A-bombs for WWII early on, he thought "you would have to turn the county into a factory". When "Nicholas Baker" showed up in the US, he observed we'd indeed done just that.
- sandworm101 11y agoI would argue that plutonium breeding is only obvious after you have performed some criticality experiments with an appreciable-sized block of enriched uranium. This was new physics at the time, without computer simulations. Bomb theory, critical mass, could only be understood after you get your hands on some enriched uranium.
- hga 11y agoIndeed, but there's a chick and egg problem there. We put the plutonium process fully in gear before we even knew the average number of neutrons a Pu-239 fast fission would produce, when we had no more than micrograms or so of cyclotron produced stuff. Which was enough to work out the separation chemistry, ultra-microchemisty is amazing. I guess my point here is that the Germans realized uranium separation was a no-go for them, were trying reactor based approaches, and they might have rolled the dice that way and tried the plutonium path. I'm saying the pieces were in play to possible success, not that it was at all likely without 20/20 hindsight.
- InclinedPlane 11y ago
- tomphoolery 11y ago"The amount of effort necessary to build bombs during the 40s was ridiculous." Apparently, the act of enriching Uranium is too expensive (in more ways than just money) for any organization other than an entire nation, and a rich nation to boot...and that is why we don't have terrorist attacks involving nuclear weapons. Let's hope it stays that way.