3 ms·
More precisely, an index fund owning both Coke and Pepsi wants profits from the soft-drink market to grow bigger, and the easiest way for that to happen is for
by makomk 11y ago
More precisely, an index fund owning both Coke and Pepsi wants profits from the soft-drink market to grow bigger, and the easiest way for that to happen is for both companies to increase their prices at the same time. Note that this is exactly the opposite of how competition in capitalism is meant to work - it's meant to drive down prices towards the cost of production, increasing overall efficiency as it does. Note also that this likely also results in selling less soft drinks than if the companies were actually competing, because increasing prices generally decreases sales.
- fweespeech 11y agoI'm not sure that is an actual problem. Generally, executives get compensated in stock in some way in their company. So the Coke C-Suite is motivated to compete with the Pepsi C-Suite even if the board members are the same for both companies.
- eitally 11y agoI think it is a problem. Unless you've worked in one of these industries where there are a handful of major players and rough parity of capability between them (like consumables, electronics manufacturing, heavy industry, oil & gas), corporations trade execs on a regular basis, and when those execs jump ship for a competitor they often lure away a good number of their key staff, too. So not only do you end up with a bigger overall market if they all do well, you end up with leadership (both executive staff and board members) who knows the ins & outs of everyone. It is in everyone's best interest for everyone to succeed, but if a company falters significantly it becomes either an acquisition target or it slowly fades away as key talent migrate to competitors. Not only this, but if you attend the earnings calls for corporations in the same sector (or even better, if you're lucky enough to attend one of their investor & analyst days), you'll see firsthand how the analysts are wined & dined, and how closely everyone knows everybody else. It's a big game that creates a ton of wealth at the top -- as long as the status quo is roughly maintained and change is incremental.
- ethbro 11y agoI understand what you meant, but wealth being created at the top is a bit charitable. Let's call it like it is: it's reallocated from consumers (vs. a more competitive market) and from shareholders (vs. a more competitive management landscape). Regulatory capture should have a management capture analog. ;)
- eitally 11y agoYes, you are of course correct. :)
- ucaetano 11y agoCoke and Pepsi don't compete only with themselves, they compete for a "share of stomach" with a huge number of other drinks and foods. Rising prices for soft drinks can drive people to those other drinks, eventually eroding profits.
- ethbro 11y agoI am intrigued by your more broadly diversified stomach-based ETF and wish to subscribe to your newsletter. (Or, in other words, hypothetically as a high-level investors, you'd want indices that track needs, not particular fulfillment thereof.)
- ucaetano 11y agoI don't have any, but there are plenty of needs-focused ETFs in the market, just pick and choose. For example: http://money.usnews.com/funds/etfs/consumer-goods-funds/vanguard-consumer-staples-index-fund/vdc http://money.usnews.com/funds/etfs/consumer-goods-funds/vang... That's the beauty of ETFs, there is a massive number to pick and choose from, representing so many different sectors of the economy.
- avn2109 11y agoHowever those "other drinks and foods" are also owned by Kraft, Altria, Nestle, and FritoLay, which are in turned owned by the same index investors, so we've just pushed our antitrust argument up one level of metaness. Yes, I know some of these have probably bought others of these, I'm not up on food industry M&A
- ucaetano 11y agoIt's way more complex than that. Coke and Pepsi compete with tap water, owned by the local utility, as well as fruits and even the local snack stand, since sometimes people have enough money to buy a coke OR a snack, but not both. In other words, it is far too complex. In Brazil, for example, a major competitor of Pepsi and Coke on the at-home segment if fruit sellers on traffic lights. People can buy a bag of oranges for a buck or so, and make a lot of healthy juice out of it, instead of spending 5X for a sugary drink. And if there's opportunity to invest in companies which are undervalued due to being out of indexes, believe me, there will be plenty of people doing it.