I don't think it's helpful to pick a single article from either Wikipedia or Scholarpedia and judge the site on that. I do think that the SEP/Scholarpedia model

I don't think it's helpful to pick a single article from either Wikipedia or Scholarpedia and judge the site on that. I do think that the SEP/Scholarpedia model of trusted experts has significant advantages over the Wikipedia model. With Wikipedia it is sometimes painfully obvious that the text is a compromise between different editors.