7 ms·
Hulbee – A Safe, Smart, Innovative Search Engine
- QUFB 11y agoThis looks advertisement supported? It appears that a visual advertisement for Coke appears in the left frame, no matter what the search term is.
- wyldfire 11y agoAdvertisement-supported and privacy focused need not be mutually exclusive.
- logicallee 11y agoit's ironic that QUFB's (gp) specific complaint includes that the ad appears "regardless of search term", despite that this is maximally privacy-preserving: the only thing it gives away is that you came from the search engine. He would be happier if ads were served that had some connection - no matter what - with search terms! (To an immediate loss of some theoretical privacy, which is true even if referral links are not sent, simply by virtue of campaigns having some connection to searches.)
- Kenji 11y agoFranky, I'm a fan of how those advertisements are tied into the site. Not flashy or obstructive, classy, embedded into the tile grid. No garbage tracking scripts loading, no plugins, just a simple colour image (from the same domain!!). If all ads were like that, I'd throw away my uMatrix and Adblock.
- dfc 11y ago> I'd throw away my uMatrix and Adblock. Well you should throw one or the other away. Why do you use both at the same time?
- Kenji 11y agoI use both in conjunction because AdBlock removes ads while simultaneously fixing the flow of the site, while uMatrix leaves gaps and holes in the site. But I need uMatrix to be safe from XSS (unfortunately, most websites include jQuery from a different domain, what a stupid practice). Also, uMatrix breaks a lot of sites (especially sites using content delivery networks on multiple domains) so if I really want to access the content, I open it in an incognito window and disable uMatrix temporarily on that site (it's tedious to figure out what exact request broke the site. I only do those manual exceptions for my most favourite sites). Like that, the site works but most of the tracking and the ads are still blocked ;) Yes, it is sad that the state of the internet has degraded so much that this is necessary.
- dfc 11y agoI ran adblock+noscript for many years for the same reason. Thats why I am suprised you would want to deal with two extensions when you could just use umatrix. What "flow" does adblock fix? Like I said, I have had a similar setup for probably a decade now. So no, I don't think that it is a sad state of affairs that adblock/noscript/umartix are necessary. Did the "state of sexual intercourse" need to degrade to a certain level in order for condoms to be necessary?
- Kenji 11y agoLet me illustrate my problem with a little image of the youtube homepage (top image is with both activated, bottom is with only uMatrix): http://i.imgur.com/RQ7VM0z.png http://i.imgur.com/RQ7VM0z.png Did the "state of sexual intercourse" need to degrade to a certain level in order for condoms to be necessary? No, because the risks have always been around and thus predated condoms. Still sad and worthy of improving, if possible.
- dfc 11y agoI dont have that issue: http://i.imgur.com/W05ZxpC.png http://i.imgur.com/W05ZxpC.png But I still use noscript with umatrix, so it might be a noscript surrogate "fixing my flow.". Do you have "hide placeholders" selected in umatrix? Risks have always been around.
- jacquesm 11y agoYes, they're done very well. Sponsoring doesn't automatically need to mean that you check your privacy at the door.
- mda 11y agoA -meta- search engine. "In partnership with Bing" "Powered by Yandex" etc etc
- 0942v8653 11y agoLooks like it gives almost the same results as DuckDuckGo -- which is to be expected given DDG also uses Bing and Yandex. I like it a lot less, though, with the animations and ad on the side of the screen.
- karussell 11y agoDo you have a link for 'bing'? I found the yandex in the translations only (yet)
- Aoyagi 11y agoEh... if I compare this http://puu.sh/jqh03/af70af5769.jpg http://puu.sh/jqh03/af70af5769.jpg and this http://puu.sh/jqh3V/56749ce4cc.png http://puu.sh/jqh3V/56749ce4cc.png , I think I'll stay with DDG.
- dfc 11y agoYou make it seem as if the reason for your DDG preference is self evident. What is the big difference to you? Is it that the first result's info box is so far to the right?
- Aoyagi 11y agoLess bloat, instant results, lack of images nobody asked for, and yes, it doesn't waste screen space by trying to fit into a narrow noodle to the middle of the screen.
- Hermel 11y agoI prefer Hulbee for its in my opinion more appealing design. In particular, I like that the search results are in the center of the screen and not on the left half.
- Aoyagi 11y agoIt's not like you can't change that in DDG's settings :P http://puu.sh/jrd5U/09515744a5.png http://puu.sh/jrd5U/09515744a5.png
- rocky1138 11y agoIs there a search engine which returns only https results? Meaning all of the results are https sites.
- anc84 11y agoI dont know that but you can force HTTPS Everywhere to only allow HTTPS connections.
- klapinat0r 11y agoHTTPS Everywhere only forces HTTPS when it's possible. Force-TLS and HTTP Nowhere does what you describe.
- rocky1138 11y agoYes to both, but I meant a search engine that only gives results which, themselves, use https. Either a standalone search engine or as a DDG or Google query flag, e.g., query: home siding repair -protocol:http
- anc84 11y agoI know and I kinda hate its name for it... I could have sworn it also had an option to only allow HTTPS connections with error as fallback. But I guess I saw that in some other add-on. Sorry for the false information!
- captaincrunch 11y agoYou lost my interest when I saw an ad manager in your HTML source: adannonce.com. I'll stick with DuckDuckGo thanks. You can't be privacy focused when you're already giving away data to a 3rd party. I see a "Clear my activity" link, why would it keep my activity at all? https://hulbee.com/Utils/ClearSettings?returnUrl=%2F%3Fquery%3Dnsa%26region%3Dbrowser%26uiLanguage%3Dbrowser https://hulbee.com/Utils/ClearSettings?returnUrl=%2F%3Fquery... Surly you could have afforded a better certificate than a C+ graded GoDaddy one? Sure, its 2048 bit SSL, but that is quite the SSL chain for being privacy focused. https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=hulbee.com https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=hulbee.com -vs- https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=duckduckgo.com https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=duckduckgo.co... Offering advertising on a privacy focused search engine? Could work, but when you're marketing to privacy focused individuals, you've just lost them. In the end, I'm from Canada, my connection routes through New York (like most North American connections). My privacy is still being abused by greater forces whom likely have at least one of the private keys for one of the many certificates that make up that GoDaddy certificate, so I'll likely just stick with Google, or perhaps even DuckDuckGo.
- Hermel 11y ago> You lost my interest when I saw an ad manager in your HTML source: adannonce.com Are you aware that adannonce.com belongs to Hulbee? Loading ads from adannonce.com should not bother you more than loading ads from hulbee.com . And the fact that it contains ads is no secret. Please do your research before crying wolf in future.
- captaincrunch 11y agoThanks for the info, care to dive into my other concerns?
- Hermel 11y agoWhile an SSL certificate from GoDaddy is not ideal, attacks are still detectable in theory by verifying the public key of Hulbee independently of the chain of trust. What I personally would be more concerned about is the fact that DuckDuckGo is hosted by Amazon. As an US company, Amazon is required to collaborate with US three letter agencies by law. Thus, whatever is hosted by Amazon is within reach of the NSA. In contrast, Hulbee is hosted in Switzerland on servers which are under physical control of Hulbee.
- jevgeni 11y ago> Safe. Smart. Innovative. The minute any business describes itself as "innovative", I assume they write everything in PL/SQL.
- outworlder 11y agoPretty much. I've once done an informal "research", comparing some of the worst software sweatshops that I know against companies such as SpaceX. The metric used was the number of references to "innovation" and "innovative". The results were very interesting. Highly recommended.
- willu 11y agoI don't get it. Because truly innovative companies don't write SQL? Is this some kind of ORM or NoSQL snobbery?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoNo. It's just that the word "innovative" spoken by a company is the dead canary that tells you the company is so full of bullshit that the methane vapours are creating a fire hazard.
- jevgeni 11y agoNo, it's like TeMPOraL said. I could've said ABAP4, but (thankfully) not a lot of people are aware of it.
- jacquesm 11y agoJudging by the top comment I think they lost on the 'safe' bit, probably on the 'smart' bit too. They may still win on 'innovative'.
- a3n 11y agoI've always thought that when a company tells you that their product has some quality like safety or quality, instead of showing it to you with their product, it's likely that that's the extent of that quality in their product: the declaration.
- bobajeff 11y agoI wonder if it would be possible for a nonprofit organization to fund such a "hybrid search engine" with wikipedia scale donations. If so that would be better than trusting all of these small companies to not sell you out a week before IPO.
- eevilspock 11y agoOf course it is possible. But the forces that work against it are incredibly powerful. Consider this: If before Wikipedia existed someone proposed to create an online encyclopedia that anyone in the world could anonymously edit, that it be funded by donations and that it become the encyclopedia that most people refer to, nearly 100% of us would have rolled on the floor and laughed out loud.
- bobajeff 11y agoIt might not even be possible if Google, Bing, Yandex had TOS that required the use of their ads networks (negating the point of it being funded by donations).
- _lce0 11y agoI'd love DDG to be that organization, although not sure if it's already too late as they are for-profit and got series A funding around 2011
- captaincrunch 11y agoMy previous comment didn't get so much attention, perhaps this will... https://hulbee.com/?query=perl%20-e%20'print%20%22%3CIMG%20SRC%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fkt-media.knowtechie.netdna-cdn.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2014%2F12%2Fhacker1.jpg%3E%22%3B'%20%3E%20out®ion=en-CA&uiLanguage=browser https://hulbee.com/?query=perl%20-e%20'print%20%22%3CIMG%20S... Edit: I had an example of displaying the IP address back to the user from my server, but it went over capacity in a few short minutes, so I took it down and removed the link. I am sure everyone gets the point, specially with a lot of the other examples provided by other HN users below. Here is a screen shot for future reference: http://imgur.com/PkAGhqn http://imgur.com/PkAGhqn
- eevilspock 11y agoRed herring. Serious bugs have been found in lots of respect worthy software and service efforts. It just needs to be fixed. You are holding a toddler up to the standards of a pre-teen (which is the highest I'd put Google). The question here is whether this is a respect worthy effort at privacy protection. EDIT: Flaws or holes have been found in Tor. Does that mean we reject the Tor effort outright? If anything, the holes found in Tor are more serious and fundamental, because they raise doubts about Tor's approach and whether their goal can ever be achieved. An HTML injection hole in Hulbee is simply an issue of incomplete execution of their vision, which may or may not be forgivable depending on the technical and non-technical circumstances (which none of us here know yet).
- captaincrunch 11y agoI admire their efforts, but serious efforts need to start with the fundamentals.
- pjc50 11y agowhether this is a respect worthy effort at privacy protection If they've launched with an HTML injection vulnerability, their security infrastructure is not sufficient to protect your privacy. Game over.
- 11y ago
- zeeed 11y agoalso try https://hulbee.ch/ https://hulbee.ch/ (they are a swiss company, after all) for entertainment.
- simon_vetter 11y agohulbee.ch uses an invalid security certificate. The certificate is only valid for the following names: *.hulbee.com, hulbee.com
- kolev 11y agoThe animation with the mosaic is just terrible - a visual distraction and slowness no search engine needs.
- briholt 11y agohow tall is mt everest? https://hulbee.com/?query=how%20tall%20is%20mt%20everest%3F®ion=browser&uiLanguage=browser https://hulbee.com/?query=how%20tall%20is%20mt%20everest%3F&... vs. https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=how%20tall%20is%20mt%20everest%3F https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=how%20tall%20is%... Hulbee can correlate the words "mt everest" to "Nepal," but it can't give me the actual answer. That's weak for a engine that claims to be "the first intelligent answer engine because it is based on semantic information recognition and offers users intuitive help in their search for answers."
- KirinDave 11y agosighs, looks at old Powerset swag from 2008, sighs again
- AstroChimpHam 11y agoIt's 2015, and this is a search engine. Why is there no autocomplete? You guys should check out https://www.constructor.io https://www.constructor.io
- FractalNerve 11y agoIs this an A/B test? See for yourself: https://hulbee.com/imprint https://hulbee.com/imprint | https://swisscows.ch/imprint https://swisscows.ch/imprint These sites `appear` to be exactly the same, I wonder what the difference is other than the design, branding and domain. I've been using https://swisscows.ch https://swisscows.ch for almost 6 months now. and was sharing it with my friends and family. Even made it the default on a lot of devices from friends and family. No negative feedback so far! I also shared it with you: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9628904 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9628904 So far there are only one two things that make me go back to google.com in rare occassions. On google "<search-term>" strictly gives me results with that term, that's appears not working similarly on hulbee/swisscows. If only I could sort search results by date and `strip results older than x` I would have no more reason to "google". What I really like about swisscows is the image and music search. One questions bugs me: How does it work? I mean the results have the same and sometimes even higher quality than google. BIG +: No self-/government-/geo-censored results like on google/bing, I can find so called "illegal URLs" (links that don't appear on the big sites like DMCAed links and results for certain stopwords) #bug: There is a bug on Firefox on Android in the image search. Clicking results opens a modal window with the resulting image below the viewable region. Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/KClGfUO.png http://i.imgur.com/KClGfUO.png
- kungfooman 11y agoAlerta alerta, it's censoring more than Google, try searching for a pussy!
- putzdown 11y agoI'm too bad of a typist to use this. Intending to search for xcworkspace I typed wcworkspace. Google gracefully corrects me. Hulbee stares at the blank wall of no results. I want to like it, but if you want to replace my entrenched tools you've got to start by matching their basic functionality.