4 ms·
It made sense because it was the only thing holding Kickstarters accountable to the people funding them. With an investment, you're taking a risk but have some
by makomk 11y ago
It made sense because it was the only thing holding Kickstarters accountable to the people funding them. With an investment, you're taking a risk but have some control over how the company's run. With a pre-order, you have no control but they have to deliver the product or refund you. Kickstarter now is the worst of both worlds: projects don't have to deliver anything and you can't even make sure they give it a decent try. Someone could promise the Earth, use the money to pay all their friends living costs for years while they tool around and fail to make a working product, then say "sorry, the money's all gone" and that's fine now according to Kickstarter.
- ghaff 11y agoYes, but an ostensible requirement that the promised reward or a full refund had to be delivered no matter what simply never made any sense. You can't get blood from a stone and all. Now, like then, you could pursue legal action but this isn't a realistic option in most cases, at least outside of clear fraud. The current ToS does it pretty clear that not delivering a project or a full refund is a bad thing and also outlines other obligations. But, by not imposing requirements that are typically just not realistic to meet with most failed projects, to me it establishes a more useful baseline for behavior.
- makomk 11y agoWe already have a way of dealing with these kinds of debts that can't be repaid: it's called bankruptcy, it has a whole bunch of safeguards to stop people abusing it, and it's what you'd have to do if you took on any other kind of debt to fund your business and couldn't repay it. There is absolutely no reason why Kickstarter needs to be any different.
- ghaff 11y agoSo now the Kickstarter project which has increased its costs by incorporating (though that's probably a good idea in any case) spends its remaining funds on bankruptcy lawyers and there's now nothing to return to the backers. Nothing is certain and Kickstarter projects certainly aren't. Whatever the ToS, it's probably not something you should use if you're looking for "satisfaction or your money back" sort of guarantees.