3 ms·
It’s not literally an identical criticism, that’s just an analogy. The point is that both epistemic critiques are similarly “political”, in the sense that they
by jacobolus 11y ago
It’s not literally an identical criticism, that’s just an analogy. The point is that both epistemic critiques are similarly “political”, in the sense that they are about professional norms and goals and are abstracted from the precise details of the work in question.
Anyway, his primary point isn’t about “mathiness” per se, but rather about the way (he claims) a particular group of economists refuse to admit that their theory turned out to be wrong when put to real-world tests. The “mathiness” part is just one of the ways he thinks they try to deflect criticism through confusion/obscurity.
(Note, in my comments here I’m not judging the validity of any of these arguments one way or the other.)