2 ms·
I agree that they are overplayed for effect, but there is some math. I saw Kissinger explain it when asked about nukes killed the whole world ten times over.
by sandworm101 11y ago
I agree that they are overplayed for effect, but there is some math. I saw Kissinger explain it when asked about nukes killed the whole world ten times over.
The math started with WWII Germany. They kept reasonably reliable records of where and when people died during allied air raids. So someone drew up a formula linking the tonnage of bombs dropped with the number of dead on the ground. This was then extended to nukes and their power measured in thousands (kilo) and millions (mega) of tons of TNT. So bombs with explosive power greater than all of WWII (a common description) could "kill" as many people as an entire war. Kissinger was correct in saying that all the bombs in the world would not, could not, destroy everyone ten or twenty times over.
This false analogy was also part of debates during Vietnam. Many, on both sided of every argument, used the math to estimate the number killed by US bombing raids, ignoring the fact that German cities and Vietnam jungle are in no way analogous.
- ptaipale 11y agoQuite; particularly considering that the strategies of the bombings were reversed. In WWII, Germany was bombed so that strategic bombers (B-17) attacked strategic targets (civilians and factories in cities), and tactical bombers (P-47) attacked tactical targets (tanks or trains near combat). In Vietnam war, Vietnam was bombed so that strategic bombers (B-52) attacked tactical targets (jungle with suspected Viet Cong activity in combat area), and tactical bombers (F-4) attacked tactical targets within strategic targets (a bridge in Hanoi). And WWII was the last "good" war for Americans.